webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of GrInfo in The Burnt Prince-GOT SI

Review detail

GrInfo
GrInfoLv121mthGrInfo

I have read most of this authors books, and they are all pretty great fanfics. I greatly enjoy the writing style, and how the protagonists don’t have op cheats, and live full lives, I also enjoy that I don’t have to read dozens of chapters of the childhood phase when we can just get a summary, and flashbacks in later chapters. The reason I gave this specific novel a lower rating is because I don’t quite like the protagonist or the ‘contradictions’. It seems as if the protagonist is a saint mostly while most of his enemies are only seen in a dark light much like his other fanfics in GoT, I believe this to be because the author has a huge bias for the Targaryens not that it is a wrong thing, I personally just don’t care for them that much. I have read many fanfics about the protagonist being transported into GoT, and becoming a Targaryen, then going about saying “I am a dragon!”, etc…, gaining a huge pride, and somehow giving a crap about bloodlines. This fanfic is 1 of them, and as such I dislike it but the writing is great, and I don’t want people to dislike this author. My personal opinions once more, if you are someone who was isekai’ed, then you should not easily believe in these things such as “I am a dragon” etc…, you should be more inclined to think your blood has been experimented to have dragon blood but that doesn’t make you a dragon. The protagonist is considered extremely kind, and cares for the common folk yet he would kill Tywins men to ignore his test, and show him what happens if he faces Targaryens, and he says only the Starks have ‘somewhat’, ‘somewhat’ justified for rebellion?! He knows his father was awful, and these rebellions are mostly justified. Also, why would he try to go save his father when he was in Duskendale!? Another thing, he judges others (many fanfic protagonists do, not only this one) despite knowing that only he knows because of his Isekai knowledge, if he didn’t, he would have no right to judge them, and if he knows, talk about it in subtle ways. Finally but not least (there are several other things why I dislike this protagonist) he feels almost like a Mary sue in that he is kind, more gentle than Rhaegar, 1 of the greatest swordsman who can fight Arthur despite being somewhat injured before hand, and is extremely intelligent. (Intelligence I can understand, he is Isekai’ed, being kind, and gentle, and caring for the common folk, I can understand, being skilled with the sword, I can let pass by but it’s becoming to much for me, especially when he was probably just an average person before.) Many of the characters that are not on the main characters side are just criticized over, and over again seemingly, though I can see this as the perspective of the characters, and not the author, I feel as if I can see the authors biases. Also, several of the characters seem far more strong willed or different than what they should actually be like, and there are certain theories that the author chooses to make real that I dislike but it’s creative liberties, especially since it’s not so hard canon in the real source material anyway so I can’t complain to much. I have probably left many things unsaid which I wanted to write but this is getting to long, anyway, this fanfic, and the authors other works are far above many other fanfics I’ve read (I have read over 20 GoT fanfics, did not finish them all or get past many of them halfway or even several chapters but still read more than 4 chapters each, if just 1 chapter, I have read close to 40 GoT fanfics), and I give this author a recommend.

altalt

The Burnt Prince-GOT SI

Drkest

Liked it!

LIKE
empty img

No replies. Be the first!