webnovel

Review Detail of M_Static in Harry Potter: The Golden Viper

Review detail

M_Static
M_StaticLv48mthM_Static

frustrating read... MC veiled in forced mystery field. He knows the plot but dont remeber it. AT outright refuses to demonstrate to us what MS is capable of. The only thing we have are blurry impressions of people who are familiar with him. It’s also disappointing that the author drags things out so much. You have 100% read various novels and fics and come across moments when a “teacher or master” withholds information from a student, giving vague explanations with a grin, saying that “you are not ready yet” and it frustrates - the whole ff feels exactly like that.

Harry Potter: The Golden Viper

FicFrenzy

Liked by 18 people

LIKE

Replies3

FicFrenzy
FicFrenzyAuthorFicFrenzy

I don't want to spoil anything BUT If you have read till the latest chapters or first about two hundred chapters then you must know that there are clues which say the MC intentionally stripped his own memories or something happened to his memories kr stuff related to his memory. So Was he truly reborn in this world without memories or did something happen? ............

midgetydeath:There are plenty of stories that do that and the writer uses creativity to make his or her own story. It is on the writer to handle that. Otherwise, there is no reason at all to have a character with any knowledge of the canon at all and would fit better as someone who naturally exist in the setting. No memories, no reincarnation, no transmigration, etc.
FicFrenzy
FicFrenzyAuthorFicFrenzy

If i give MC the memory then he can just bulldoze through the plot of Harry potter without any mystery and you readers may like it for 5-10 chapters but after that it will be typical and boring. So it is what it is, it is for the plot and the mystery surrounding the story that MC doesn't have his memory and i will give a valid reason for this at the upcoming chapters.A small spoiler iam gonna describe the Mc's Backstory in the upcoming new chapters soon.

midgetydeath
midgetydeathLv4midgetydeath

There are plenty of stories that do that and the writer uses creativity to make his or her own story. It is on the writer to handle that. Otherwise, there is no reason at all to have a character with any knowledge of the canon at all and would fit better as someone who naturally exist in the setting. No memories, no reincarnation, no transmigration, etc.

FicFrenzy:If i give MC the memory then he can just bulldoze through the plot of Harry potter without any mystery and you readers may like it for 5-10 chapters but after that it will be typical and boring. So it is what it is, it is for the plot and the mystery surrounding the story that MC doesn't have his memory and i will give a valid reason for this at the upcoming chapters.A small spoiler iam gonna describe the Mc's Backstory in the upcoming new chapters soon.