webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of ok_ok_1494 in Harry Potter: The God of Magic (BEING REWRITTEN)

Review detail

ok_ok_1494
ok_ok_1494Lv11yrok_ok_1494

Its a great concept but, the author does not have the capabilities to actually fully bring it to life. There are many plot holes and the MC who supposedly has lived for hundreds of times now, if pretty stupid.

altalt

Harry Potter: The God of Magic (BEING REWRITTEN)

LazyCaveman

Liked by 48 people

LIKE

Replies8

ok_ok_1494
ok_ok_1494Lv1ok_ok_1494

yes it did

mow:I'd rather not read about a childish MC, especially if he has lived countless times. Did it change with those two new chapters you talked about?
LazyCaveman
LazyCavemanAuthorLazyCaveman

I’m sorry you feel that way, but the plot holes that I’m assuming you are speaking of are only there because the story is only 7 chapters long at the moment, in due time things will be more fleshed out I just didnt want to do a complete overhaul in the first few chapters. Thanks for the feedback!

ok_ok_1494
ok_ok_1494Lv1ok_ok_1494

by plot holes I mainly meant that he does not act like someone who has lived countless times and has died countless times, his mentality is of a child and his entire house, does not feel like its an ancient house (it does not have "proper" procedures and stuff for example, when his grandparents parents were killed, why did his grandfather launch a full out attack and weaken their forces why did he not "hire" other wizards and in the first place why was his great grandfather alone, he is a head off an ancient house)

LazyCaveman:I’m sorry you feel that way, but the plot holes that I’m assuming you are speaking of are only there because the story is only 7 chapters long at the moment, in due time things will be more fleshed out I just didnt want to do a complete overhaul in the first few chapters. Thanks for the feedback!
LazyCaveman
LazyCavemanAuthorLazyCaveman

Ah I see then that’s on me for not fully explaining what happened, and for the first point of the mc’s attitude, im actually writing the next chapter at this moment which explains that. And to clarify, the mc great-grandfather wasn’t alone, he had theodoric’s two brothers with him along with their personnel which I’m also going to explain in this chapter as a side convo between Alaric and his grandfather. If you have any more questions please ask me!

ok_ok_1494:by plot holes I mainly meant that he does not act like someone who has lived countless times and has died countless times, his mentality is of a child and his entire house, does not feel like its an ancient house (it does not have "proper" procedures and stuff for example, when his grandparents parents were killed, why did his grandfather launch a full out attack and weaken their forces why did he not "hire" other wizards and in the first place why was his great grandfather alone, he is a head off an ancient house)
ok_ok_1494
ok_ok_1494Lv1ok_ok_1494

the two new chapters have mainly cleared it up, after a few more chapters I will either edit this review or make a new one

LazyCaveman:Ah I see then that’s on me for not fully explaining what happened, and for the first point of the mc’s attitude, im actually writing the next chapter at this moment which explains that. And to clarify, the mc great-grandfather wasn’t alone, he had theodoric’s two brothers with him along with their personnel which I’m also going to explain in this chapter as a side convo between Alaric and his grandfather. If you have any more questions please ask me!
LazyCaveman
LazyCavemanAuthorLazyCaveman

Yeah I’m sorry for the early plot holes I explained in the chapter I just released but I like to write in almost puzzles and stuff like that

ok_ok_1494:the two new chapters have mainly cleared it up, after a few more chapters I will either edit this review or make a new one
mow
mowLv4mow

I'd rather not read about a childish MC, especially if he has lived countless times. Did it change with those two new chapters you talked about?

ok_ok_1494:the two new chapters have mainly cleared it up, after a few more chapters I will either edit this review or make a new one
mow
mowLv4mow

As in he's no longer acting childish? I'll take your word for it and read then.

ok_ok_1494:yes it did