webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of EyeOfSilver in Douluo dalu:God Punishment List

Review detail

EyeOfSilver
EyeOfSilverLv121yrEyeOfSilver

I dont really understand the hate behind tang san and his teacher tbh I have read the novel and watched the anime and still fail to see why hes hated so much

altalt

Douluo dalu:God Punishment List

Akkuzz_69

Liked by 15 people

LIKE

Replies46

Uksmal
UksmalLv4Uksmal

The hatred you have for these characters is that they believe their actions are on the right side, a typical case of Chinese MCs of that genre of stories. The same author of the story says that his MC is a bad apple.

Jack_Ryu
Jack_RyuLv1Jack_Ryu

In addition, he does not understand the amount of difficulty he has caused to those less fortunate, for Spirit Hall helped awaken Spirits for those les fortunate and even supplied them with teaching and gold coins, and I bet you the nobles would have never done this. Tang-San awoke his Spirit from them and if he was poor, he would have never gotten this chance form the nobles. He even took their Gold Coin payments and then calls them evil. what the heck is that? He thinks of them as evil, while never considering all the good they do and I know every organization has good/bad people, but Spirit Hall is for the people and I know no other organization in that world that works as that.

EyeOfSilver
EyeOfSilverLv12EyeOfSilver

Pretty sure the conflct their only really happened is because of the conflict between tang hao and spirit hall then tang san had conflict because of the tournament where they tried to kill xiao wu, so i get your point in that spirit hall helped those less fortunate but they made mistakes and paid the price for doing dirty deeds

Jack_Ryu:In addition, he does not understand the amount of difficulty he has caused to those less fortunate, for Spirit Hall helped awaken Spirits for those les fortunate and even supplied them with teaching and gold coins, and I bet you the nobles would have never done this. Tang-San awoke his Spirit from them and if he was poor, he would have never gotten this chance form the nobles. He even took their Gold Coin payments and then calls them evil. what the heck is that? He thinks of them as evil, while never considering all the good they do and I know every organization has good/bad people, but Spirit Hall is for the people and I know no other organization in that world that works as that.
Jack_Ryu
Jack_RyuLv1Jack_Ryu

Yes, I understand they made mistakes and got their comeuppance, but that still does not shy away from destroying it, for I doubt anything like that was created that helped the common man or how long it took, leading the nobles to get stronger and letting the common man suffer. Heck, he joined with the Imperial family, for goodness sake and even disrespected/disregarded the sect that raised his father, who destroyed the Clear Sky Sect and made it become a hidden set. I used to not think about this and thought of Tang San as nothing, but I have come to see him being deeply flawed and his actions caused untold suffering. He became a God, but abandoned his roots.

EyeOfSilver:Pretty sure the conflct their only really happened is because of the conflict between tang hao and spirit hall then tang san had conflict because of the tournament where they tried to kill xiao wu, so i get your point in that spirit hall helped those less fortunate but they made mistakes and paid the price for doing dirty deeds
Akkuzz_69
Akkuzz_69AuthorAkkuzz_69

I quite understand what do you mean...You will understand about that when we go deeper in to the novel.. : )

Monkey_is_hungry
Monkey_is_hungryLv4Monkey_is_hungry

I have read too much fanfic that hated tang san that when I tried to read the original feels weird so I stop after a couple chapter

Gabichu_Yeah
Gabichu_YeahLv3Gabichu_Yeah

There are mini stories from the future of Douluo continent, and honestly I felt a little sad. I read it in several fanfics and I read the original to check and thinking about it logically I was disgusted by Tang San. h There is a mini story from the future of the Sixth Tang (a sect that Tang San created before going to the god realm) and it was about how a poor girl had to sell herself to buy medicine for her relative. If Spirit Hall had existed, that would not have happened, because after Spirit Hall disappeared, nobody woke up the spirits of poor people. and only the noble and rich could awaken their spirits which they used to intimidate the poor people, greatly widening the social difference between poor and rich. B.Basically everything Tang San did was trash

EyeOfSilver
EyeOfSilverLv12EyeOfSilver

You make a fair point sigh but you have to remember what tang san did was trash but that doesnt mean spirit hall was innocent either honestly if i had to choose a side i would choose neither and just stop both from murdering each other

Gabichu_Yeah:There are mini stories from the future of Douluo continent, and honestly I felt a little sad. I read it in several fanfics and I read the original to check and thinking about it logically I was disgusted by Tang San. h There is a mini story from the future of the Sixth Tang (a sect that Tang San created before going to the god realm) and it was about how a poor girl had to sell herself to buy medicine for her relative. If Spirit Hall had existed, that would not have happened, because after Spirit Hall disappeared, nobody woke up the spirits of poor people. and only the noble and rich could awaken their spirits which they used to intimidate the poor people, greatly widening the social difference between poor and rich. B.Basically everything Tang San did was trash
God_Of_Steel342
God_Of_Steel342Lv4God_Of_Steel342

what did Spirit Hall do wrong? All they did was kill Soul beasts. His mother was a soul beast and xiao wu was a soul beast. To them all they are doing is killing beasts to gain a soul ring and a soul bone.

EyeOfSilver:You make a fair point sigh but you have to remember what tang san did was trash but that doesnt mean spirit hall was innocent either honestly if i had to choose a side i would choose neither and just stop both from murdering each other
God_Of_Steel342
God_Of_Steel342Lv4God_Of_Steel342

He destroyed Slaughter Capital because he didn't want anyone to get a god-given domain causing the evil Spirit masters to escape and then for the future there would be nowhere to imprison the evil Spirit masters

EyeOfSilver
EyeOfSilverLv12EyeOfSilver

Thats what they did wrong in tang sans eyes and hence why the conflict started i explained from tang sans point of view sorry that your ability to understand english isnt great

God_Of_Steel342:what did Spirit Hall do wrong? All they did was kill Soul beasts. His mother was a soul beast and xiao wu was a soul beast. To them all they are doing is killing beasts to gain a soul ring and a soul bone.
EyeOfSilver
EyeOfSilverLv12EyeOfSilver

evil young masters are bad he did good so shut up

God_Of_Steel342:He destroyed Slaughter Capital because he didn't want anyone to get a god-given domain causing the evil Spirit masters to escape and then for the future there would be nowhere to imprison the evil Spirit masters
EyeOfSilver
EyeOfSilverLv12EyeOfSilver

gg good logic battle thanks for letting me win emjoy ur day

God_Of_Steel342:He destroyed Slaughter Capital because he didn't want anyone to get a god-given domain causing the evil Spirit masters to escape and then for the future there would be nowhere to imprison the evil Spirit masters
Mohd_Rizuwan
Mohd_RizuwanLv4Mohd_Rizuwan

that why I really hate him the author practically let he do what he want without any consequences and he okay with that

Gabichu_Yeah:There are mini stories from the future of Douluo continent, and honestly I felt a little sad. I read it in several fanfics and I read the original to check and thinking about it logically I was disgusted by Tang San. h There is a mini story from the future of the Sixth Tang (a sect that Tang San created before going to the god realm) and it was about how a poor girl had to sell herself to buy medicine for her relative. If Spirit Hall had existed, that would not have happened, because after Spirit Hall disappeared, nobody woke up the spirits of poor people. and only the noble and rich could awaken their spirits which they used to intimidate the poor people, greatly widening the social difference between poor and rich. B.Basically everything Tang San did was trash
Jack_Ryu
Jack_RyuLv1Jack_Ryu

How is that a win? All the points made prove him being evil and even though Spirit Hall has done evil, it better for them to be in the world, than for him. Who provided for the poor, who awoke there spirits, who paid for their education and protected the continent from evil soul masters: Spirit Hall. I won't lie that they have evil in them, but what they do for the voiceless severely outweighs that and it may be brainwashing or something else, but tell me, when they are at the bottom of the wrung with no hope to going higher, except for becoming either evil soul masters or selling themselves to become one, what should they do cause I bet you they would tell you something way different from what you are saying.

EyeOfSilver:gg good logic battle thanks for letting me win emjoy ur day
Phenix_Rox
Phenix_RoxLv14Phenix_Rox

Divine Emperor of Death Great novel. In start it's like a silly novel because I think its author's first novel. But after 300, story build up well. After 1200+, story will get better, and it led readers to curious about what happen next. Some misunderstanding happens (like you will get wrong ideas for some scenarios) if you read around 300 or little less chapters because you will think it's just an OP or something not right to read because it's silly novel. But just trust and read at least 1500+ chapters and you will find those early worries not necessary and lot of OP(like death note) will come up with lot of restrictions. (Those are figured in novel by MC) Novel gets very interesting and now its lot more with cliffhangers (I'm at 2513). Also, author discount (99%) 3rd tire privileged chapter for just for 90 coins. For unlock 3rd tire 90 coin, each chapter also 1 coin (99% discount) Include 6 chapters for that tire. Also join his discord channel there you can clarify about your doubts about some chapters, if you feel novel will get wrong direction or not right in your sense. because author like to mislead readers (like teasing) and write entirely different stories. Also, author like to hang the reader's lot of cliffhangers. So, if you think it's not right to read story because you think it wrong like something happen, then you can ask it on discord spoiler channel and clarify what will happen next by fellow readers and continue to read.

EyeOfSilver
EyeOfSilverLv12EyeOfSilver

Gg man thx for the W

Jack_Ryu:How is that a win? All the points made prove him being evil and even though Spirit Hall has done evil, it better for them to be in the world, than for him. Who provided for the poor, who awoke there spirits, who paid for their education and protected the continent from evil soul masters: Spirit Hall. I won't lie that they have evil in them, but what they do for the voiceless severely outweighs that and it may be brainwashing or something else, but tell me, when they are at the bottom of the wrung with no hope to going higher, except for becoming either evil soul masters or selling themselves to become one, what should they do cause I bet you they would tell you something way different from what you are saying.
EyeOfSilver
EyeOfSilverLv12EyeOfSilver

Well hate to tell you soul land isnt the same as world so ur point doesnt hold up

Jack_Ryu:In addition, he does not understand the amount of difficulty he has caused to those less fortunate, for Spirit Hall helped awaken Spirits for those les fortunate and even supplied them with teaching and gold coins, and I bet you the nobles would have never done this. Tang-San awoke his Spirit from them and if he was poor, he would have never gotten this chance form the nobles. He even took their Gold Coin payments and then calls them evil. what the heck is that? He thinks of them as evil, while never considering all the good they do and I know every organization has good/bad people, but Spirit Hall is for the people and I know no other organization in that world that works as that.
EyeOfSilver
EyeOfSilverLv12EyeOfSilver

mhm yes read that 4 years ago

Phenix_Rox:Divine Emperor of Death Great novel. In start it's like a silly novel because I think its author's first novel. But after 300, story build up well. After 1200+, story will get better, and it led readers to curious about what happen next. Some misunderstanding happens (like you will get wrong ideas for some scenarios) if you read around 300 or little less chapters because you will think it's just an OP or something not right to read because it's silly novel. But just trust and read at least 1500+ chapters and you will find those early worries not necessary and lot of OP(like death note) will come up with lot of restrictions. (Those are figured in novel by MC) Novel gets very interesting and now its lot more with cliffhangers (I'm at 2513). Also, author discount (99%) 3rd tire privileged chapter for just for 90 coins. For unlock 3rd tire 90 coin, each chapter also 1 coin (99% discount) Include 6 chapters for that tire. Also join his discord channel there you can clarify about your doubts about some chapters, if you feel novel will get wrong direction or not right in your sense. because author like to mislead readers (like teasing) and write entirely different stories. Also, author like to hang the reader's lot of cliffhangers. So, if you think it's not right to read story because you think it wrong like something happen, then you can ask it on discord spoiler channel and clarify what will happen next by fellow readers and continue to read.
DaoistOrlan1016
DaoistOrlan1016Lv3DaoistOrlan1016

In think that those fanfic makes you misunderstood tang San because it's his second means that he had to be mature. But isn't it said in the story that he devoted his whole life in mastering the tang sect techniques and never really learn any about relationships so the moment he reincarnated his mind is like a child that wants to broaden his view and for those who said that he's hypocrite dude that's a cruel world and he destroys the Slaughter Capital because he thinks it's filthy without knowing that it had many consequences and honestly it would be destroyed sooner or later because tang San is bound to destroys the spirit hall to avenge his mother which is his personal matter and the other reason is after the new continent arrives there are more evil spirit which may make more chaos as they will freed those strong evil spirit masters in the Slaughter Capital and some says he never bother his roots after he ascended the reason for it I think is he can't because of certain restrictions that gods can't interfere to mortal world and honestly with his position he could have but he already makes many things out of rules like bringing his team to God realm which violates the rule where A god king can only bring limited amount of mortals and he helps other spirit beast which is against the view of other god that's why he's restricted that's all and it's only for my view

DespairHope
DespairHopeLv5DespairHope

Well I don't need to intervene in your conflict But I want to so... First of all Tang San may have dedicated his life to the sect but the reason as to why he's being called a Hypocrite is because he doesn't help those that help him in his journey, let's take a recap on his first life, what did he do to the sect that nourished him he take their forbidden technique without caring for the consequences, Now the second he's reborn he just helps his waste of a father because "He doesn't know relationship" now how about the village that helped him did he do anything to help them no, secondly he might be redeemable but the second he became Yu xiaogang's disciple then he's not redeemable at all, because he will see his master's way even if it's wrong and now you might be thinking doesn't that means he helps someone who helped him, No the only reason he helps someone is because they're in deep relation. Third did he care about consequences No he doesn't care about others only himself. Fourth He destroyed the Spirit hall not because of his mother it's because of Xiao wu. Fifth he doesn't care about in the slightest about the other soul beast or else he already done something for them but no he ruined that chance and even destroy them. Sixth his tang sect that's going on is not really helping others, it says that there goal is to help bring justice but what do they do, they just focused on doing Tang San thing, perfecting the technique. Now that's not all of his misdoings there's others too and also many people connected to him that do more bad than good. All his actions is not because he's benevolent, it's because they're only for him and yet he's portrayed as the good guy because he's the winner.

DaoistOrlan1016:In think that those fanfic makes you misunderstood tang San because it's his second means that he had to be mature. But isn't it said in the story that he devoted his whole life in mastering the tang sect techniques and never really learn any about relationships so the moment he reincarnated his mind is like a child that wants to broaden his view and for those who said that he's hypocrite dude that's a cruel world and he destroys the Slaughter Capital because he thinks it's filthy without knowing that it had many consequences and honestly it would be destroyed sooner or later because tang San is bound to destroys the spirit hall to avenge his mother which is his personal matter and the other reason is after the new continent arrives there are more evil spirit which may make more chaos as they will freed those strong evil spirit masters in the Slaughter Capital and some says he never bother his roots after he ascended the reason for it I think is he can't because of certain restrictions that gods can't interfere to mortal world and honestly with his position he could have but he already makes many things out of rules like bringing his team to God realm which violates the rule where A god king can only bring limited amount of mortals and he helps other spirit beast which is against the view of other god that's why he's restricted that's all and it's only for my view