webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of Roxanne_Woods in The Stunning Girl From The Slums

Review detail

Roxanne_Woods
Roxanne_WoodsLv141yrRoxanne_Woods

I lasted till chapter 5 then gave up. The plot is actually pretty good but the writing is just too bad. Let's forget about the usual mistake he/she/his/her, the ML's name even goes from Li Yan to Li Qun back and forth, without any explanation. Sometimes, it's Li Yan one line, then next sentence we are back to Li Qun and you are supposed to understand it's the same person. The bad translation makes it very difficult to actually understand what's going on. The way sentences are written doesn't always make sense and I often had to re-read the same sentence several times to understand. Does the translator even respect the readers? Is it so difficult to have someone else beta-read the novel to provide the readers with a good book? How can anyone expect readers to pay for something like this? I really don't know what Webnovel is doing --'

altalt

The Stunning Girl From The Slums

JQK

Liked by 6 people

LIKE

Replies8

94owl
94owlLv494owl

From what you've said, it's probably machine translated? Mistranslating names is usually a tell-tale sign of MTL?

Roxanne_Woods
Roxanne_WoodsLv14Roxanne_Woods

Probably 🧐 They still could have re-read the translation. There are people on the Internet who provide free MTL novel after they have done some work on the translation to make it clean. Since it's not free here, they could have at least check it 😡 ... To be honest, I'm kind of p*ssed. It's not the first time Webnovel does something like that but I feel like it happens more and more now.

94owl:From what you've said, it's probably machine translated? Mistranslating names is usually a tell-tale sign of MTL?
94owl
94owlLv494owl

It's not surprising. With the number of new novels they're putting out, they probably can't sustain quality translations. As for getting angry... It depends on what your expectations were. I expected the worst so 🤷‍♀️ I do wish they'd own up and *say* that they're using MTL (if they are - and if they're not, they need to train their translators).

Roxanne_Woods:Probably 🧐 They still could have re-read the translation. There are people on the Internet who provide free MTL novel after they have done some work on the translation to make it clean. Since it's not free here, they could have at least check it 😡 ... To be honest, I'm kind of p*ssed. It's not the first time Webnovel does something like that but I feel like it happens more and more now.
cindoii
cindoiiLv13cindoii

i forgot the title but actually a novel exactly the same with this already on the trial before

Aisling_Brooke
Aisling_BrookeLv1Aisling_Brooke

You are so right when i first read it , it reminds me of a novel but i too don't remember it's name

cindoii:i forgot the title but actually a novel exactly the same with this already on the trial before
Aisling_Brooke
Aisling_BrookeLv1Aisling_Brooke

Young Master Ji, Young Madam Are So Multifaceted i think this is the one

cindoii
cindoiiLv13cindoii

you're right! this is it. deym they changed the titles lol

Aisling_Brooke:Young Master Ji, Young Madam Are So Multifaceted i think this is the one
Aisling_Brooke
Aisling_BrookeLv1Aisling_Brooke

Yeah but it also didn't have much chapters and this one has more chapters compared to the previous one

cindoii:you're right! this is it. deym they changed the titles lol