webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of Magecrafter in SPELLCRAFT: Reincarnation Of A Magic Scholar

Review detail

Magecrafter
MagecrafterAuthor1yrMagecrafter

After clocking over three hundred chapters, I will be giving my novel a Review. Firstly, I would like to say that while I am the author, my opinions on this book isn’t just based on bias. It’s a wonderful and interesting story. I have received a few criticisms, of which I will be addressing here. As readers, you should also be prepared to see these factors. So that you’re not caught off guard, let me explain a few things. [Sp0iler Alert] *Some things mentioned may contain mild sp0ilers* Firstly; The MC acts like a kid even though he’s supposed to be an old sage internally. Secondly; The Academy Arc makes no sense because of how Mc is treated despite being of nobility Thirdly; Cliche routes like Demons and Academy being implemented Fourthly; The reasons behind some of Mc’s seemingly risky/immature actions Lastly; The story’s progression To answer those major criticisms, I have made this Review. Answer 1: If you’ve ever watched Black Clover, or some similar Anime, you tend to notice some old personalities who act immature at times. An example is Julius Novachrono. Thanks to his love of Magic, and his goofy personality, he acts like a child sometimes. However, no one can deny how epic he is when he needs to be. That’s exactly the same as the MC. If you’re patient enough and just accept this aspect of him, you’ll love his character more He’s meant to be more relatable and expressive. Don’t expect an ‘Ayanokoji’ for the MC He behaves childish sometimes, but he really isn’t. Those who have gone further in the story (especially the third arc) can testify to this. Answer 2: Ainzlark Academy is purely meritocratic Even the Prince of the Kingdom attends, and the only reason he’s regarded well is because of his talent for Magic. The MC’s path to success isn’t known by anyone, so they would naturally ostracize him by their standards But, it isn’t permanent, so please… don’t get too annoyed. Answer 3: This novel may seem cliche from the start, but it’s nothing like that at all. Some argue that the Academy was unnecessary, but that’s a lie. If you read the story well, you’ll understand why I went down that route. As for Demons, it’s not as simple as many works have depicted their existence. Again, you need to read the story to find out. Answer 4: The MC is very smart. If you’ve reached the third arc, you’ll understand this perfectly well. Even from the first arc, you begin to see traces of his intelligence. Not just Magic, but strategy and knowledge in other fields. But, some of his actions may seem a little off. Please do not impulsively judge Many people dropped the book at first arc because they were too stuck up with their belief of the MC Unknown to many, in the third arc, the MC explains the rationale behind his seemingly rash action. Everything the MC does has a reason. I don’t mean he’s perfect and he’s always right. But… he’s not stupid. Answer 5: At some point, I changed the POV. Criticisms appeared because I didn’t focus on the MC for some chapters. But, please understand that he’s not the only important person in the story. Other important characters will be introduced. I certainly hope you enjoy this story. Cheers

altalt

SPELLCRAFT: Reincarnation Of A Magic Scholar

Magecrafter

Liked by 31 people

LIKE

Replies59

Elijah_Frost_7392
Elijah_Frost_7392Lv3Elijah_Frost_7392

is there romance in the novel?

Magecrafter
MagecrafterAuthorMagecrafter

There is But it’s not a major focus. It’s a wholesome story, so romance is included

Elijah_Frost_7392:is there romance in the novel?
ImmortalFantasy
ImmortalFantasyLv4ImmortalFantasy

Is it harem?

Magecrafter:There is But it’s not a major focus. It’s a wholesome story, so romance is included
Magecrafter
MagecrafterAuthorMagecrafter

No

ImmortalFantasy:Is it harem?
ImmortalFantasy
ImmortalFantasyLv4ImmortalFantasy

Nice. Btw, will the fmc be strong too? I like op couple lol

Magecrafter:No
Magecrafter
MagecrafterAuthorMagecrafter

It depends on who you’re talking about There are currently three main female characters One of them is especially strong. Stronger than the MC even The other two are talented and pretty decent (not comparable to MC’s level tho)

ImmortalFantasy:Nice. Btw, will the fmc be strong too? I like op couple lol
Juan_Cuevas_6382
Juan_Cuevas_6382Lv13Juan_Cuevas_6382

Why is their 3 fmcs if he’s only finna get with one?

Magecrafter:It depends on who you’re talking about There are currently three main female characters One of them is especially strong. Stronger than the MC even The other two are talented and pretty decent (not comparable to MC’s level tho)
Magecrafter
MagecrafterAuthorMagecrafter

There aren’t three FMC. There’s no FMC. There are just important female characters. And they aren’t restricted to only three. For now, there are three important girls close to MC’s age. It could change anytime

Juan_Cuevas_6382:Why is their 3 fmcs if he’s only finna get with one?
Grey_01l
Grey_01lLv2Grey_01l

Personally I prefer the fmc to be the espically op one cause for the other two one is like a little sister and the cold silent type troupe is a little over use. The espically op one has the most interesting personality and she also doesn't like the mc but another person so it would be fun to see how her feelings change

Magecrafter:It depends on who you’re talking about There are currently three main female characters One of them is especially strong. Stronger than the MC even The other two are talented and pretty decent (not comparable to MC’s level tho)
Magecrafter
MagecrafterAuthorMagecrafter

Lol I can't tell you who he's gonna end up with, but... it's going to be an interesting ride Beside, romance is just a side piece. It's not exactly the focus of this book.

Grey_01l:Personally I prefer the fmc to be the espically op one cause for the other two one is like a little sister and the cold silent type troupe is a little over use. The espically op one has the most interesting personality and she also doesn't like the mc but another person so it would be fun to see how her feelings change
DefyingDemon
DefyingDemonLv11DefyingDemon

When do you plan on starting the romance ?

Magecrafter:Lol I can't tell you who he's gonna end up with, but... it's going to be an interesting ride Beside, romance is just a side piece. It's not exactly the focus of this book.
Magecrafter
MagecrafterAuthorMagecrafter

It has started already Lol

DefyingDemon:When do you plan on starting the romance ?
DefyingDemon
DefyingDemonLv11DefyingDemon

Who’s the fml??

Magecrafter:It has started already Lol
Magecrafter
MagecrafterAuthorMagecrafter

There’s no definite one Only candidates You can choose the one you prefer later on. I already know the one he ends up with tho And I’m not spoiling

DefyingDemon:Who’s the fml??
DefyingDemon
DefyingDemonLv11DefyingDemon

So when will that answer be revealed don’t tell me it’s towards the end of the novel?

Magecrafter:There’s no definite one Only candidates You can choose the one you prefer later on. I already know the one he ends up with tho And I’m not spoiling
Ratnamoni_Deka_0706
Ratnamoni_Deka_0706Lv2Ratnamoni_Deka_0706

I think Maria would be the most suited. Her character has growth potential.

Magecrafter
MagecrafterAuthorMagecrafter

We shall see, won't we?

Ratnamoni_Deka_0706:I think Maria would be the most suited. Her character has growth potential.
Magecrafter
MagecrafterAuthorMagecrafter

I haven't decided on the definite point yet I'll ask readers once I'm done with this Arc.

DefyingDemon:So when will that answer be revealed don’t tell me it’s towards the end of the novel?
DefyingDemon
DefyingDemonLv11DefyingDemon

Tbh I hope it’s at least around the middle part of the the novel not towards the end.

Magecrafter:I haven't decided on the definite point yet I'll ask readers once I'm done with this Arc.
Magecrafter
MagecrafterAuthorMagecrafter

I'll drop hints, definitely But... like I said, this novel isn't romance based. I'm trying to avoid any Waifu wars or something But, if you want spoilers, then you should ask on the Discord server. I'll happily tell you who he ends up with. LoL

DefyingDemon:Tbh I hope it’s at least around the middle part of the the novel not towards the end.