webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of Gh0st00 in Marvel: Reborn As Gilgamesh

Review detail

Gh0st00
Gh0st00Lv152mthGh0st00

so how many times is this story been rewritten or stopped or put on hiatus or pick back up I mean this story is about a year old that tells you something and it's got what 10 11 chapters something like that it had more at one point then it had less and then it had more and then it had less and then it had none and it started over again they started over twice now

altalt

Marvel: Reborn As Gilgamesh

Gilgamesh_Official

Liked by 4 people

LIKE

Replies5

Emanuel_Wheeler
Emanuel_WheelerLv13Emanuel_Wheeler

You have 22 reviews and 14 of those are people who I doubt are actual people are giving you 5 Star reviews without actually saying what’s good about it nor any criticism. Only 8 reviews have any criticism in them. This makes most stories and reviews untrustworthy.

Gilgamesh_Official:But I still stand my point, because the positive reviews/comments I got until now, which are way more than 50, are very well structured, and they don't just simply praise me or something, they tell me things I can work on besides of telling me what they liked about my way of writting the story, they motivate me, unlike this negative review, which the main concern is criticising the fact that I have redone the beginning of this fanfic in the past. No story building criticism, no writing quality criticism, just about the fact that I did 2 rewrites. I could rant more about the reason of why I did the rewrites, but you don't want to know that, I just wanted to prove my point.
Gilgamesh_Official
Gilgamesh_OfficialAuthorGilgamesh_Official

Overreacting much? I posted the story a year ago for some 6 or 7 chapters. Didn't like it so, ended up trying to re-write it, unfortunetly I have a life and things got too chaotic, and I ended up not able to continue. So I erased the chapters as they didn't have enough quality or length. Started writing for fun once again 2 months back, and picked up the love for it. Wrote like 10k words(16 chapters) for the sake of it, but it wasn't there yet, thus, I did the recent rewritte(2nd), and its going well, with 11 chapters(18k words now), and I am seeing a lot of good feedback. Plus I am having fun writting it, finally. So, my advice? Don't like it, run along little "...must tell you something." Your review next to 20 postive comments giving me good and positive criticism, doesn't mean that much. Thats the thing about quality and length of the chapter, it matters a lot. Who cares if I am currently with less chapters than before if it has more words, more length and more quality? Have a good day.

Emanuel_Wheeler
Emanuel_WheelerLv13Emanuel_Wheeler

I’d rather trust a negative review than a lot of positive reviews

Gilgamesh_Official:Overreacting much? I posted the story a year ago for some 6 or 7 chapters. Didn't like it so, ended up trying to re-write it, unfortunetly I have a life and things got too chaotic, and I ended up not able to continue. So I erased the chapters as they didn't have enough quality or length. Started writing for fun once again 2 months back, and picked up the love for it. Wrote like 10k words(16 chapters) for the sake of it, but it wasn't there yet, thus, I did the recent rewritte(2nd), and its going well, with 11 chapters(18k words now), and I am seeing a lot of good feedback. Plus I am having fun writting it, finally. So, my advice? Don't like it, run along little "...must tell you something." Your review next to 20 postive comments giving me good and positive criticism, doesn't mean that much. Thats the thing about quality and length of the chapter, it matters a lot. Who cares if I am currently with less chapters than before if it has more words, more length and more quality? Have a good day.
image
Gilgamesh_Official
Gilgamesh_OfficialAuthorGilgamesh_Official

Same here. Doesn't mean that what I said is wrong though.

Emanuel_Wheeler:I’d rather trust a negative review than a lot of positive reviews
Gilgamesh_Official
Gilgamesh_OfficialAuthorGilgamesh_Official

But I still stand my point, because the positive reviews/comments I got until now, which are way more than 50, are very well structured, and they don't just simply praise me or something, they tell me things I can work on besides of telling me what they liked about my way of writting the story, they motivate me, unlike this negative review, which the main concern is criticising the fact that I have redone the beginning of this fanfic in the past. No story building criticism, no writing quality criticism, just about the fact that I did 2 rewrites. I could rant more about the reason of why I did the rewrites, but you don't want to know that, I just wanted to prove my point.

Emanuel_Wheeler:I’d rather trust a negative review than a lot of positive reviews