webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of Saadido in Reborn As Harry Osborn - Marvel

Review detail

Saadido
SaadidoLv45yrSaadido

This is gonna be a harsh review as this fiction has potential. Let's just start by saying, the author only has determination and a cool idea going for him currently. The writing quality is non existent. Huge blocks of text with non capitalized "I"s, but the worst part is that it reads like a stale cracker, dry. The author tells you what is happening with no context, emotions or humanity. Stability of updates I have no complaints with. Story development is way too fast paced. The characters have no time to develop. Which brings us to Character design. It's simply non existent. World background is not explained mentioned or touched upon. Overall a waste of time currently but with hopes of improvement. To the author: read a novel then write a novel. Don't watch a movie and try to type one down. Assume the reader knows nothing and try to bring them into your world. Good luck.

altalt

Reborn As Harry Osborn - Marvel

godfreyngsze

Liked by 71 people

LIKE

Replies24

godfreyngsze
godfreyngszeAuthorgodfreyngsze

Noted. i admit i am not a good writer will try my best to put more emotion and slow it down a little but no guarantees. I don't have the time to write in very details which might make each chapter around 5k per chapter(based on good writer and i don't have the time and energy and capital). I am planning to write 2 to 3 chapter for each event so please be patient with me. Correction will be done when i am free. Thanks for the feedback. Can't seem to find any of our novels.

godfreyngsze
godfreyngszeAuthorgodfreyngsze

your novels

Saadido
SaadidoLv4Saadido

my novels?

godfreyngsze:your novels
godfreyngsze
godfreyngszeAuthorgodfreyngsze

do you write

Saadido:my novels?
Saadido
SaadidoLv4Saadido

I read. I think I've read a couple hundred books if you don't count fan fiction if you do then it's upwards of 2 thousand. What is your point exactly?

godfreyngsze:do you write
godfreyngsze
godfreyngszeAuthorgodfreyngsze

No reason. relax just asking since you have high expectations and requirement as a reader, I thought you are a pro writer

Saadido:I read. I think I've read a couple hundred books if you don't count fan fiction if you do then it's upwards of 2 thousand. What is your point exactly?
void893
void893Lv11void893

As a reader these are the reviews I want to see. It clearly outlines issues and good parts. Thank you! I hope the author really takes in your advice.

godfreyngsze
godfreyngszeAuthorgodfreyngsze

noted. will try my best

void893:As a reader these are the reviews I want to see. It clearly outlines issues and good parts. Thank you! I hope the author really takes in your advice.
Saadido
SaadidoLv4Saadido

Sorry m8 and thank you, but I didn't write anything that is good enough to share.

godfreyngsze:No reason. relax just asking since you have high expectations and requirement as a reader, I thought you are a pro writer
InnerVoice
InnerVoiceLv6InnerVoice

Damn bro, you really have a way with words. The advice you gave to the other is actually pretty good

Saadido
SaadidoLv4Saadido

thank you

InnerVoice:Damn bro, you really have a way with words. The advice you gave to the other is actually pretty good
MiLfL0VeR
MiLfL0VeRLv12MiLfL0VeR

Yeaps cause like me the marvel universe that i know is the movie one not the comics one And i thing the comics have much more stories than the movies? So my knowledge to spiderman comes from the movies not the comica

Fatty_Cream
Fatty_CreamLv5Fatty_Cream

That was kind of a scummy thing to do, i mean criticism can be seen as an attack on your character, but it really shouldn't. Usually, it's with the intent of trying to improve someone else craft as people do not see flaws within their own works as easily as other people do. Perhaps it wasn't what you meant but your response came off as defensive, the friendly response then resorting to not so subtly shutting down his criticism with if he had written before. No his criticism still stands and i think it encapsulated some problems i found even before reading, which was the synopsis. The synopsis needs to be edited, as even though i could understand the gist, it didn't flow at all and i had to put it together with the shambles of broken grammar strewn. Anyways this concept you came up with is quite neat, but the quality leaves much to be desired. I hope you improve!

Criyxen
CriyxenLv14Criyxen

Exp 😂😂😂

TheDemonNazI
TheDemonNazILv4TheDemonNazI

I have no idea why I keep seeing this. Is it an abbreviation of something?

Criyxen:Exp 😂😂😂
Criyxen
CriyxenLv14Criyxen

It mean experience bro for us to increase our cultivation level 😂😂😂 to breakthrough in our cultivation 😂😂😂😂

TheDemonNazI:I have no idea why I keep seeing this. Is it an abbreviation of something?
Zerak
ZerakLv11Zerak

Some people are better at improving things and automising them than making new things. This why you have editors and publishers helping authors improve their work instead of writing their own work. I have yet to read you work yet so I can’t really comment on that though. I’ll drop you a review once I read enough of it to feel like i know how to rate it and what to point out about it. It seems like an interesting story though from the reviews I have read.

godfreyngsze:No reason. relax just asking since you have high expectations and requirement as a reader, I thought you are a pro writer
ExodusGaming555
ExodusGaming555Lv6ExodusGaming555

Well dont be upset author as you are making a fanfic not an original novel. So of course theres a lack of world building and character designing as this is a fan fic and youre still quite new to this. Well theres sometimes a fanfic that was created with good world background changes but it was usually done by a a more talented/experinced authors like they say either you're born with it,grow with it, or never have it. Plus english is not yore native language right? So yeah that also explain grammar in it too.so dont be sad ok you're doing a good job as a quite new author ^_^ peace✌️

godfreyngsze:Noted. i admit i am not a good writer will try my best to put more emotion and slow it down a little but no guarantees. I don't have the time to write in very details which might make each chapter around 5k per chapter(based on good writer and i don't have the time and energy and capital). I am planning to write 2 to 3 chapter for each event so please be patient with me. Correction will be done when i am free. Thanks for the feedback. Can't seem to find any of our novels.
TiananmenSquare198
TiananmenSquare198Lv5TiananmenSquare198

Wait is this an actual review with criticism and not just "good" what the actual f*ck?

RandomMobA
RandomMobALv4RandomMobA

I totally agree with this. This could have been a dozen times better if its slower with more development instead of jetpacking his way over everything. Also about the characters being bland is pretty spot on. Imo all characters in here is pretty much categorized as being a horny chicks, horny dudes or a yes man boys/girls. Everyone just practically thinking of horny or isn't thinking at all