Dr_Monke
Since he’s a werewolf, you have a unique opportunity to make it so he can get both of them. It won’t and shouldn’t be without some drama, but I think the story is set up in a way that you have a really good opportunity to pull it off well. Question is, is this the kind of thing you think you could pull off or simply have no confidence doing? Or is it that you simply have no interest in attempting it, since you simply don’t like it? If you have to choose just one, then Bloom. If you wish to grow as a writer, you could do as I suggested and learn, and attempt a three way relationship between them. There are very few stories where it could be done reasonably well, and this is one of them so I hope you can consider it.