webnovel
avatar

Comments of chapter undefined of Harry Potter and The Descendant of Merlin

EndOfTheGlory
EndOfTheGloryLv5EndOfTheGlory

Honestly, it would of been cool if I wasn't taking in account that it was 11-years old talking to old manipulator, many times more accustomed to politics, that he is aware of his facade instead of playing oblivious. What the hell, he is child, acting all smartass and badass in front of strongest publicity known wizard on the island? If I would be in place of Dumbledore, I would of laughed at his naivitate. Like, really, although Dumbledore can't really harm him at school he has more than enough means to make his life difficult. He has no power to defend himself, only escape(I still think this cloaking spell is not absolute, so almost sure someone at the level of Dumbledore will be able to find him), he has no political advantage - his Merlin's Descedant name is more of nameplate "use me" instead of real political power - so he is basically defendless throwing threats to the strongest person in the village. What. The. Heck?

BoiGeorge
BoiGeorgeAuthorBoiGeorge

There's many things Oz can hold above Dumbledore and many reasons why he initiated this sort of rebuke. First, Dumbledore's main slipup was his curiosity leading to his rush to get the events sorted, with what happened to Oz this year, Oz only need explain to certain people who know his identity and word would spread. A headmaster allowing a student to be bullied. The teachers of the school, including those that are necessarily more 'angrier' would be easily coaxed into becoming witnesses for Oz and backing him up. Two, Merlin's Descendant as an Identity is a nameplate but that identity is heralded miles higher than what anyone would initially expect (and Dumbledore knows this) after all, The ministry is putting in actual effort to shield Oz's identity until Oz was okay with showing it and this was all due to Oz just requesting it at Gringotts (Think about it, Dumbledore is within the ministry yet had to discover the identity on his own. Thats how tightly locked it was). There's a BIG difference between 'Supreme Mugwump, second coming of Merlin' and 'Literal Merlin's proven descendant'. Paired with Dumbledore's drive to discover Oz, he wouldn't just suddenly act against Oz, Oz is purely showing his stance to Dumbledore by stating 'I don't want to be under you as you plan, I have higher goals and am not going to be restrained to Hogwarts'. Whilst he's harsh in his rebuke, he's not necessarily spitting sophistry, he's literally saying it how it is. Dumbledore's intentions were twisted and the headmaster himself knows it as he straight up apologised for this curiosity that led to a rushed and somewhat botched situation on his part due to his own rush in regards to what's happening starting next year. Three, Oz showed intelligence that he has 'some' idea of the events to come. He scratched the tip of the iceberg, as if only 'guessing', but he insinuated he knew what would happen next in the wizarding world and 'canon'. This would place him high in Dumbledore's eyes and sure, Dumbledore will place suspicion on him. With that amount of intelligence though, on the level of foresight, Dumbledore would be hard pressed to try anything as he cant predict what Oz knows or will do. On top of this, Hagrid is in the room as well, this is an incredibly important part and a defining factor as to why Oz is saying any of this in the first place. Finally, If word is to spread of this event with Dumbledore, Dumbledore's actions in Hogwarts towards Oz, Oz's identity and everything building to this point, the first person who'd be a suspect if anything happened to Oz would be Dumbledore due to how he treated Oz in the year and if this event spreads between the headmaster and Oz, (think about the people who are aware this meeting is happening), people will start to be suspicious of Dumbledore and his intentions with Oz, the descendant of merlin. So the main factors as to why Oz has charged forward with this sort of situation; Merlin's descendants identity holds weight, Hagrid being present, Oz's own foresight, the people who are angry and aware of this event happening and finally Oz's words aren't necessarily wrong or straight up antagonistic, he's simply stating what he thinks due to being subjected to purposeful bullying by a headmaster with too much curiosity. With Oz's talent, his lineage and now his intelligence, Dumbledore would deem it a waste to lose such a person considering the climate of the wizarding world soon. Hearing Oz's words he will change his plans, knowing Oz isn't simple and the way to 'approach' him would need to be more delicate as he's not a simple 11 year old boy. I hope this explains somewhat what im going for, a bit of an info dump I admit though so I apologise for the wall of text hahah To finalise all this; Dumbledore in my novel is 'Chaotic Neutral/Lawful Evil (if need be)'. He wouldn't attack Oz purely because of this and Oz knows that.

Suvraneel_Paul
Suvraneel_PaulLv4Suvraneel_Paul

Ohhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh saavvvaaagggeee!!!!! Love some Dumbledore bashing.bash the whole chessboard on his head

CodeSpectre
CodeSpectreLv4CodeSpectre

CephJester
CephJesterLv2CephJester

I'm getting some dark-lord dumbledore vibes...

1Dreamer_Owl
1Dreamer_OwlLv41Dreamer_Owl

Oz:

Jonathanjtj
JonathanjtjLv4Jonathanjtj

I like that heheheheh Mc: Turn Down for what

Allhavens
AllhavensLv11Allhavens

someone might end up feeling the dragon's wrath.

Ashlin_17
Ashlin_17Lv12Ashlin_17

love this chapter

Loolix
LoolixLv4Loolix

Daoist423242
Daoist423242Lv4Daoist423242

I like this version of oz than the first one!!

Aeon_Storm
Aeon_StormLv15Aeon_Storm

A lot of the versions people write of Dumbledore have him be the manipulative chess master, not always evil but wanting people to be his pawns. If I was lucky enough to be reborn as a wizard in a Harry Potter universe I would be content to lay low then go off and do my own thing and explore magic.

Charles_Warriors
Charles_WarriorsLv2Charles_Warriors

he's quite brave in saying that to dumbledore's face, I'm not saying that the headmaster is bad or anything like that or will hurt him, but a big flaw that mcs have is being too bold almost bordering on arrogance in front of someone who he is stronger than them, there was nothing wrong with the mc accepting dumbledore's help only until he was stronger than him and stabbed him in the back, what i mean is that the mc entered dumbledore's playing field and voldemor as a third side without having enough strength or allies yet, he is basically alone against everyone

Pfisch
PfischLv15Pfisch

Love it! F dumbledore!!!

Travis_Btmb
Travis_BtmbLv13Travis_Btmb

Thanks for the chapter

asdasdssf
asdasdssfLv1asdasdssf

I mean being so arrogant and confrontational isn't really good. He could have just said something like "just spare me of your games in future" and be done with it.

DaoistF0koDD
DaoistF0koDDLv2DaoistF0koDD

Buenos capitulo

I_dont_believe_it
I_dont_believe_itLv14I_dont_believe_it

When can expect the next chapters?

Alenzure
AlenzureLv13Alenzure

Thanks for chaps dude

Lvec
LvecLv4Lvec

Thanks for the chapter

Daoist248604
Daoist248604Lv4Daoist248604

FAMHDTVPNG
FAMHDTVPNGLv3FAMHDTVPNG

thanks for the chapter