Comments of chapter undefined of Re-Birth of a Genius. Creator/Destroyer

No guns and bikes. Also I think you went too far with the whole reactions thing. I mean Sam threatened them, but it's not like something super serious happened and sam became a monster or something. He did the right thing. He can cripple tons of nobles in a tournament without fearing the consequences and now a threat is not good?

The gun Hate is super dumb. As is the idea guns only hurt mortals like futuristic fantasy guns, fantasy chemicals, and such aren't something that exist or could be made. For all this guns let people promulgate their disgusting ideas easier it's like people ignore it let's them promote good ones easier too. And honestly this is billed as modern super genius in cultivation land. Seeing eastern fantasy go full xuanhuan science fantasy like 40k of cultivation is half the reason I read this.

I don't know about guns. Because in this world you can infuse energy in weapons and things like that. But a gun, you don't touch the bullet, so you can't infuse energy in the bullets. So for me, guns are useless in a world like that (useless at higher levels). A bike can be cool but there is the probleme of mobility. But anyways for me, a bike is cool. You just need to find a way to integrate it to the scenario. Thx for the chap.

Bike is useless he is fast by him self and has beasts that are faster and will be faster as they grow stronger. Only use of bike is to sell and gain fame and money. For guns only sniper rifle that is enhanced with formations and his spiritual energy will be of use for ultra long range stealth attacks. Something like particle gun that charges and goes attacks with speed of light. Since it would be charged with his energy it would be useful even against stronger beings since it is focused energy. Since he has light element he could get optical invisibility by bending light around himself or range attacks.

Well first of all thanks for the Chap also I dont mind you using guns but I would prefer if u use some kind of application of modern knowledge, like using a nuclear powerplant (or at least the principles behind it) to fuel stuff like cultivation or inscriptions

No guns unless you make it possible that only Sam will use it and make it later in the story where his inscriptions are unmatched and can’t be replicated about bikes and the others they aren’t needed nor any transportation method since they are cultivators it will become a hindrance so not needed

dont see why you shouldn't add them add away if anything he can use them as enjoyment or even make a suped up cultivator version of them

No guns

I think bikes and stuff like this are fine, but I dont really like guns etc

Dude i also think you make the nobles seem a lot too stupid if im being honest, like honestly howd you try to threaten someone without doing research on them or their character, as nobles that should be rule #1, second after you check their background you should look at the benefits that person can bring to their background, and for sam you think the artisan, inscription and formation towers would allow you to kill someone with such talent and not wipe you out afterwards to warn others?

Bruh ik this aint going to change anything cause i basically just started this novel, but having guns is not a problem like if its the basic modern gun sure its a problem but the thing is this is magic based world creating magic weapons such as guns that can launch spells and shit is not impossible, even if its only a regular gun, at the stage he is at now he can well and use it and dominate alot of people, but ill advise you to do stuff like regular guns in a kingdom build type novel and then evolve that gun to a magic based gun after the first hundred or so chapters depending on how fast the novel progress or how many chapters you estimate the novel to finish at when you finish your plot. Honsetly guns arent bad it depends on the materials you use to constuct them, cause im sure this current world would have way more resources to use than earth

throwing in my $.02; while I would love to read about the technical aspects involved in the development of magical guns , especially if involves combining multiple specialties like it should (cross-artisan profession) to create the weapon, there are a lot of details to think about before going that route.. which is why I think most authors don't do it. like it was already stated in the earlier chapters, guns give power to just about anyone and honestly become a gamebreaker in fantasy/magical series, unles given some drastic flaw or limitation. again , I've always enjoyed seeing how an author uses their creative powers to marry technology and magic. i think the groundwork has been laid for this to happen, but I would hate to see the mc come up with a 100% effective trump card this early in the story (keeping in mind I'm now about 200 chapters behind at the time of reading this)(also keeping in mind that the mc doesn't like guns) As far as bicycles go, I see it being plausible. they're not super advanced technology if you keep in mind the first bikes were all single gear. I would point out they'd only be plausible to use in cities and towns with stone or cobble roads, and not widely used in the overgrown wilds that have been described outside of the towns and cities in the story. also, the mc seems interested in keeping his inventions to himself at this point and bikes are easy to copy. I'm surprised the mc hasn't come up with unseen methods to use his light attribute in an offensive manner like a laser or active camouflage besides movement and healing abilities (again, 200 chapters behind)

Both a mount and a range weapon can be useful, but he kinda already has a companion as a mount (exept the times they seperate), and the issue with guns is of course that they may fall in the wrong hands. Maybe delay the bike for now - after all, he did make plans before, while resenting guns - and have him obtain a solid user restriction that literally can't be bypassed at all before you approach any of this. Something that clearly reads his identity, maybe a bit like the spirits did. If you introduce such modern weapons at all, modify them so they make sense in a world dominated by cultivation. As for the modifications, maybe a bike could fly, drive on water, drive on vertical surfaces, have all sorts of offensive, defensive and utility surprises (healing, storage, you name it), travel faster then he does on his own (and any normal bike, that is - now when they get seperated there is a point in having it) and so on. As for guns, they could be used a bit like combat scrolls, just that they only use up ammunition (maybe made from spirit stones) so he doesn't have to perform the spell every time to reload them and the energy isn't drained from him but the item. Maybe also make them precise at ultra long range or shoot hyperspeed projectiles/spelle or something, your decision. On top of a bike with a spirit and guns, other items with the same working concepts may be an idea, for example a healing wand using the same type of energy source. I think the best way to deal with the guns and other items is to introduce a way of making these "compacted spirit stones" in different tiers and elements (consider merging elements for dual element use?) which he can only create due to his unique cultivation. Let the enemy have a gun if they can't resupply it with ammunition, ever. Lol. This would allow him to give some items to friends, maybe not sell them. As for items, mind that all sorts of stuff can be used. Imagine traps with this energy source. Voice commanded ropes to climb hills/buildings, cross rivers and pitfalls and tie up enemies. Healing and defense items. Blades that perform an advanced slash out of nowhere. Daggers shooting at your enemy from behind. Anything. It would allow him to basicly do and distribute OP inscriptions out in the open and when they get in the enemies hands or he gets betrayed they can keep and copy them all they want as they have no way to supply them with energy. Of course, this is all "late game content" as he isn't quite there yet, and it is just me suggesting some things that were on my mind for some days. While I absolutely recommend staying coherent with the past (which is part of the reason I came up with the energy source concept, as he was worried about what people may do with guns before, missing that there may be worse weapons arround already), it is of course up to you to decide wether you want to use any of my ideas. I hope my suggestions can be of any use, feel free to let me know what you think :) Regards, -NeuerGamer

I think Sam should make a general/simplified vehicle creation technique (cars/carriages and bikes powered by some type of propulsion system) and sell it to the artisan tower just to spread a general form of the technology out, that way he can make his own superior version(s) and they will stand out a lot less as they won't be strange and unique, only rare and expensive. The reasons for targeting would be to personally acquire, which will have less pressure than targetting to learn/monopolize production of a new income source. NO guns. Not crafted ones at least. Perhaps simulated/replication of the mechanics of guns/hot weapons through the use of elements/magic though. Light could be used for lasers, fire to make thermobaric explosions, if he gets earth maybe he could make mortars by combining it with fire to launch shots from crafted tubes of earth.

I think it would be cool for Sam to have a bike. Also thanks for the chap!

Guns are awesome as long as its difficult to make and only mc has it

Based on the modern genius I would say he should make some guns like maybe a sniper and a rocket launcher as for the bikes if he rides his pets they will be faster so the only thing I can see them used for is selling them to either regular people or rich people that want something unique

I'm impressed with how he treated Kelly in this chapter. All the hardships in the orphanage might have added to this

Really a well written novel..