webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of SaikiKusu in I'm Really Not A Nen Exorcist (HxH Fanfic)

Review detail

SaikiKusu
SaikiKusuLv24mthSaikiKusu

this is a chinese fanfic, wrote by Purple blue pig, here is the original. 猎人:我真不是除念师 you can find it in mtlnation, mtlnovel, etc...for free!

altalt

I'm Really Not A Nen Exorcist (HxH Fanfic)

God_of_Chicken

Liked by 17 people

LIKE

Replies7

BulletHell_Newb
BulletHell_NewbLv1BulletHell_Newb

The problem here isn't whether it's good or bad, it's that the person is not disclosing that this is a translation, which makes people assume that he or she is the author. Also profiteering off the work just for translating it through patreon while none of the money actually goes to the actual author who isn't even being given any credit isn't a good look either. The least the translator could do is give the link to the original version and be honest about it.

Eternal_Aspect1
Eternal_Aspect1Lv13Eternal_Aspect1

what's the name in mtlnation ?

SaikiKusu
SaikiKusuLv2SaikiKusu

i think it's the same.

Eternal_Aspect1:what's the name in mtlnation ?
Humbuub
HumbuubLv4Humbuub

it was obviously a translation. it's up to you if you wanna read the MTL though.

Aceron
AceronLv15Aceron

MTL is not a legitimate translation, it is a horrific amalgamation of letters and words that rarely even resembles the original story that is so horrifically written that most would rather give up on what is a wonder story then suffer a literary-stroke. People that actually invest time in translating should be praised for their hard work and while not all of them are skilled enough to complete do justice to the stories they translate, their effort should be acknowledge compared to copy the original and pasting an AI generated translation

HolyDK
HolyDKLv12HolyDK

I don't like people who steal novels or fiction, for me it's a scam the least thing is to say who the author is

Aceron:MTL is not a legitimate translation, it is a horrific amalgamation of letters and words that rarely even resembles the original story that is so horrifically written that most would rather give up on what is a wonder story then suffer a literary-stroke. People that actually invest time in translating should be praised for their hard work and while not all of them are skilled enough to complete do justice to the stories they translate, their effort should be acknowledge compared to copy the original and pasting an AI generated translation
SaikiKusu
SaikiKusuLv2SaikiKusu

U r spitting facts

BulletHell_Newb:The problem here isn't whether it's good or bad, it's that the person is not disclosing that this is a translation, which makes people assume that he or she is the author. Also profiteering off the work just for translating it through patreon while none of the money actually goes to the actual author who isn't even being given any credit isn't a good look either. The least the translator could do is give the link to the original version and be honest about it.