Review Detail of PsyLoRD in Guardian of the Pacific: The Incredible Adventures of the Giant Turtle
Review detail
Not bad but not for me. i hate when mc's reincarnates as a monster and instantly goes full hero-ish type for absolutely no reason. mc could protect his own territory, or try to make a trade, maybe smt like volibear or ornn? but just going saving everything as a kaiju is just... boring, cause i'm expecting to see a kaiju as mc, and not a human. -1 star for grammar, -1 for the mc.
Guardian of the Pacific: The Incredible Adventures of the Giant Turtle
MyQuietPlace
Liked by 60 people
LIKEReplies25
yes? if y do it cause its just 'the right thing' is kinda pointless, at the end of the day 'right' or 'wrong' are not only relative but they are all just the popular opinion. Those who stand at the top determine what's wrong and what's right! Those who win the war, become the Justice. that's how our world works.
Justsome_nobody:is there a need for a reason to just be good?
Btw, i know this is a normative question, and a philosophy question with no 'definite answer', i'm not really trying to find one, or debate about it, it is just my personal opinion/belief.
PsyLoRD:yes? if y do it cause its just 'the right thing' is kinda pointless, at the end of the day 'right' or 'wrong' are not only relative but they are all just the popular opinion. Those who stand at the top determine what's wrong and what's right! Those who win the war, become the Justice. that's how our world works.
Yeah it depends on perspective but saving whole humanity from facing extenction is right according my and majority’s perspective. Unless someone is alien pretending to be human or are so selfish they dont care about anything else.
PsyLoRD:yes? if y do it cause its just 'the right thing' is kinda pointless, at the end of the day 'right' or 'wrong' are not only relative but they are all just the popular opinion. Those who stand at the top determine what's wrong and what's right! Those who win the war, become the Justice. that's how our world works.
BUT why would the mc save humanity? he is not human. that's the whole point. Also. "is right according my and majority’s perspective" if 51% of the population think 'eating babies' is a the right thing, does that mean you have to do it? should you do it?
Justsome_nobody:Yeah it depends on perspective but saving whole humanity from facing extenction is right according my and majority’s perspective. Unless someone is alien pretending to be human or are so selfish they dont care about anything else.
well to be fair i see it more like mc is just protecting his human pets and playing hero while having fun like playing a sand box game
PsyLoRD:BUT why would the mc save humanity? he is not human. that's the whole point. Also. "is right according my and majority’s perspective" if 51% of the population think 'eating babies' is a the right thing, does that mean you have to do it? should you do it?
That could be, i just wanted it to be more flashed out? y'know? mc feels empty, hollow, and very lacking.
LUBT:well to be fair i see it more like mc is just protecting his human pets and playing hero while having fun like playing a sand box game
He is human reincarnatedrnated or transmigrated in big turtle he has all his past memories and values. It is about perspective like if you like giving money to homeless people but someone might not because they might just get high with that money. Our MC thinks it is right to save humanity from going poof and i think that it is very natural. For me there are some very basic things that are right(helping someone in need, saving humanity from going poo etc) and wrong(killing innocents, destroying humanity etc). I know right and wrong concept is rabbit hole deeper you go that is why i just keep it simple i dont think if and buts and think about present.
PsyLoRD:BUT why would the mc save humanity? he is not human. that's the whole point. Also. "is right according my and majority’s perspective" if 51% of the population think 'eating babies' is a the right thing, does that mean you have to do it? should you do it?
You may be right, everyone has their own personal 'morals', and that's just fine, BUT as not everyone agrees with the same thing, you making a character do X thing for no reason = bad writing/boring. That's why i said i needed a reason, cause for people like you who completely agree with him is fine but for people like me (who disagrees) mc is just doing smt stupid, if he had a 'good reason' i could just go 'well, ok, i don't agree but i can understand' which is not the case, cause he literally is doing the right for being right (which again is relative). IRL all you said can work but in a book? that's just shallow/lacking.
Justsome_nobody:He is human reincarnatedrnated or transmigrated in big turtle he has all his past memories and values. It is about perspective like if you like giving money to homeless people but someone might not because they might just get high with that money. Our MC thinks it is right to save humanity from going poof and i think that it is very natural. For me there are some very basic things that are right(helping someone in need, saving humanity from going poo etc) and wrong(killing innocents, destroying humanity etc). I know right and wrong concept is rabbit hole deeper you go that is why i just keep it simple i dont think if and buts and think about present.
Also, you have to think that many times what is right is not the best. Even more for a non-human MC, how much would he gain if acted just for himself? and even if he acts as a 'hero' what guarantee him that they are not going to try to kill him next or smt? and if they are, its worth for him to still do it? see? he is acting 'stupid', no reasoning or anything, pure emotion, mc is trying to act selfless as a kaiju in an alien world for 0 reason, that's the whole point, i don't really care if he does save or not, i just need the reasoning behind, just doing the right doesn't work in this type of scenario.
Justsome_nobody:He is human reincarnatedrnated or transmigrated in big turtle he has all his past memories and values. It is about perspective like if you like giving money to homeless people but someone might not because they might just get high with that money. Our MC thinks it is right to save humanity from going poof and i think that it is very natural. For me there are some very basic things that are right(helping someone in need, saving humanity from going poo etc) and wrong(killing innocents, destroying humanity etc). I know right and wrong concept is rabbit hole deeper you go that is why i just keep it simple i dont think if and buts and think about present.
PsyLoRD:That could be, i just wanted it to be more flashed out? y'know? mc feels empty, hollow, and very lacking.
PsyLoRD:yes? if y do it cause its just 'the right thing' is kinda pointless, at the end of the day 'right' or 'wrong' are not only relative but they are all just the popular opinion. Those who stand at the top determine what's wrong and what's right! Those who win the war, become the Justice. that's how our world works.
InsertaGoodName:You watch too much anime and now you are confusing fiction with reality
That's your problem trusting no one or thinking that everyone is plotting something is proof that either you have a victim mentality or you are what you describe. Doing good is something you do without a second thought. Doing good requires having faith in the people around you and in yourself. Doing good is believing in your morality and that at the very end you will be at peace with yourself and without regret because at least your life will have had meaning in the great history of this world. This is the reason why children prefer Spider-Man to the Green Goblin, Batman to the Joker, Captain America to the Red Skull.
PsyLoRD:Nah. thats my creed in life. i don't trust anyone I cant understand.
"Doing good is believing in your morality" That already tells me everything about you, you believe in an imaginary thing and let it control your life. Also, yes, that's my problem, so what? That was never the debate, there are a lot of people who agree with me, there's even a whole philosophy debate from years ago till today about Morality/the need for a reason, just google it, I think it's called Hume's law or smt.
Talleyrand:That's your problem trusting no one or thinking that everyone is plotting something is proof that either you have a victim mentality or you are what you describe. Doing good is something you do without a second thought. Doing good requires having faith in the people around you and in yourself. Doing good is believing in your morality and that at the very end you will be at peace with yourself and without regret because at least your life will have had meaning in the great history of this world. This is the reason why children prefer Spider-Man to the Green Goblin, Batman to the Joker, Captain America to the Red Skull.
" This is the reason why children prefer Spider-Man to the Green Goblin, Batman to the Joker, Captain America to the Red Skull." I preferred the villains you cited over their hero counterparty as a kid(with the exception of Red Skull, I didn't like Steve cause he was a boy scout but I also didn't like Red Skull, he was just boring), so your example makes no sense, you are generalizing smt really BIG.
Talleyrand:That's your problem trusting no one or thinking that everyone is plotting something is proof that either you have a victim mentality or you are what you describe. Doing good is something you do without a second thought. Doing good requires having faith in the people around you and in yourself. Doing good is believing in your morality and that at the very end you will be at peace with yourself and without regret because at least your life will have had meaning in the great history of this world. This is the reason why children prefer Spider-Man to the Green Goblin, Batman to the Joker, Captain America to the Red Skull.
Justsome_nobody:Yeah it depends on perspective but saving whole humanity from facing extenction is right according my and majority’s perspective. Unless someone is alien pretending to be human or are so selfish they dont care about anything else.