Review Detail of Filler1_Name2 in Net Game: All My Pet Beasts Are Goddesses
Review detail
harem? really? those are actually difficult to write in a non immersion breaking way. It's usually not believeable in execution and often drags the novel down. Also, even if your pets are humanoid, it's still messed up to do things like that with them.
Net Game: All My Pet Beasts Are Goddesses
Whiteday
Liked by 20 people
LIKEReplies18
I'm adding that you're replying to a guy trying to say he's wrong while talking about something different. At this point, you're just being willfully ignorant.
Filler1_Name2:If you are going to get offended, please do it elsewhere. One is talking about how harems are always bad whilst the other is saying there are scenarios where harems don't detract so they aren't improving the story but they aren't inherently bad. If you have nothing to add to that simple thing, you are just wasting your time.
They can be good/decent if written well. What's most important is that, if you make a Harem, it's not about immediately falling in love and just wanting all the babies. A lot of people think harems are just a matter of "Oh, people back in the day could just not keep it in their pants" but it's more of a political thing. As long as the characters aren't blindly in love with each other, the characters aren't overly active in their nightly pursuits and they still exist as their own human beings with emotions, viewpoints, logic, experiences and whatever. It's all about making sure that these characters don't just exist to make some of the less mentally mature readers go "OH, YES, I WANT ALL THE LADIES! I AM SO STARVED FOR ATTENTION, I WILL GIVE MYSELF TO ANY AND ALL LADIES! GIVE ME AS MANY AS POSSIBLE SO I CAN GET AS MUCH AFFIRMATION AS POSSIBLE! MORE WOMEN MEANS MORE SUCCESS!!"
Wandering_Soul_UwU:Harem books are trash in the purest sense
Even the ones written well are still the best of the trash so they are still trash imo. Completely agree to what u say btw
Filler1_Name2:They can be good/decent if written well. What's most important is that, if you make a Harem, it's not about immediately falling in love and just wanting all the babies. A lot of people think harems are just a matter of "Oh, people back in the day could just not keep it in their pants" but it's more of a political thing. As long as the characters aren't blindly in love with each other, the characters aren't overly active in their nightly pursuits and they still exist as their own human beings with emotions, viewpoints, logic, experiences and whatever. It's all about making sure that these characters don't just exist to make some of the less mentally mature readers go "OH, YES, I WANT ALL THE LADIES! I AM SO STARVED FOR ATTENTION, I WILL GIVE MYSELF TO ANY AND ALL LADIES! GIVE ME AS MANY AS POSSIBLE SO I CAN GET AS MUCH AFFIRMATION AS POSSIBLE! MORE WOMEN MEANS MORE SUCCESS!!"
I think well written harem can certainly have it not affect people that dislike it whilst still bringing SOME level of joy to the ones that do enjoy it. Sure, you'd bring even more joy to the ones that enjoy it by going more over the top but that just completely ruins it for everybody else. So, in that way, it's possible to write a great novel and have harem be an element in it, it's just very unlikely to be a good novel in my eyes if it has harem in it.
Wandering_Soul_UwU:Even the ones written well are still the best of the trash so they are still trash imo. Completely agree to what u say btw
Yes I made a blunder a novel could still be a masterpiece. I just really hate harem a lot, even when it is well made and written I just cannot like it, I think the concept of there being an harem is actually what triggers me. Bruh women are not like that, just imagine someone’s momma building a harem… she would be called a s***. Anyway it just isn’t a good concept.
Filler1_Name2:I think well written harem can certainly have it not affect people that dislike it whilst still bringing SOME level of joy to the ones that do enjoy it. Sure, you'd bring even more joy to the ones that enjoy it by going more over the top but that just completely ruins it for everybody else. So, in that way, it's possible to write a great novel and have harem be an element in it, it's just very unlikely to be a good novel in my eyes if it has harem in it.
You need to understand that there are political marriages and at times you can have more than one of those at a time. also, if I saw a man married to multiple women, I'd mostly think poorly of him. I come from a country where women really had no say in anything. Though in many cases the women did get badmouthed, it was really the man that was looked down upon. I know a person that for political reasons got married to 4 women. He got himself his main wife whom he lives his daily life with and the others live in separate wings of the house and they only really all get together for big events like marriages and other such grand things.
Wandering_Soul_UwU:Yes I made a blunder a novel could still be a masterpiece. I just really hate harem a lot, even when it is well made and written I just cannot like it, I think the concept of there being an harem is actually what triggers me. Bruh women are not like that, just imagine someone’s momma building a harem… she would be called a s***. Anyway it just isn’t a good concept.
Filler1_Name2:You need to understand that there are political marriages and at times you can have more than one of those at a time. also, if I saw a man married to multiple women, I'd mostly think poorly of him. I come from a country where women really had no say in anything. Though in many cases the women did get badmouthed, it was really the man that was looked down upon. I know a person that for political reasons got married to 4 women. He got himself his main wife whom he lives his daily life with and the others live in separate wings of the house and they only really all get together for big events like marriages and other such grand things.
And I am trying to make him understand that political marriages are a thing. You can marry for other reasons than love and those novels can be considered harem too. Harem doesn't have to make a story worse, it just most likely will.
requiembob:You need to understand that he is talking about how women act and not how political marriages work.
Okay so you're replying to him with a completely different conversation topic and trying to force words in my mouth, cool how about no.
Filler1_Name2:And I am trying to make him understand that political marriages are a thing. You can marry for other reasons than love and those novels can be considered harem too. Harem doesn't have to make a story worse, it just most likely will.
If you are going to get offended, please do it elsewhere. One is talking about how harems are always bad whilst the other is saying there are scenarios where harems don't detract so they aren't improving the story but they aren't inherently bad. If you have nothing to add to that simple thing, you are just wasting your time.
requiembob:Okay so you're replying to him with a completely different conversation topic and trying to force words in my mouth, cool how about no.
I'm all up for romance with your beast familiar but CNs take it to awful direction and it's just terribly executed. I remember reading a good goddess pet novel but MC harem was really disgusting, the pet of heroine friend was involved but not the friend herself and then more beasts added to it. Now it just seems Heroine the only normal one in this animal harem...
Wandering_Soul_UwU:Yes I made a blunder a novel could still be a masterpiece. I just really hate harem a lot, even when it is well made and written I just cannot like it, I think the concept of there being an harem is actually what triggers me. Bruh women are not like that, just imagine someone’s momma building a harem… she would be called a s***. Anyway it just isn’t a good concept.
Lol. Who are you to decide what is logical or not in this world. Not insulting you. Anyway, in my country polygamy is legal and I know many friends from such family so no it isn't BS and no it isn't illogical. Polygamy always existed be it with humans or with animals. Since Harem exist in nature itself what makes it illogical? It isn't like the husband go and force the woman to enter the Harem (at least not in my country). The second or third wife enter the marriage while knowing the existence of the first and the first wife accepted signing a marriage under the polygamy from the start
Wandering_Soul_UwU:No. That is BS too. It just isn’t a logic concept
HIKARU_GENJI:Lol. Who are you to decide what is logical or not in this world. Not insulting you. Anyway, in my country polygamy is legal and I know many friends from such family so no it isn't BS and no it isn't illogical. Polygamy always existed be it with humans or with animals. Since Harem exist in nature itself what makes it illogical? It isn't like the husband go and force the woman to enter the Harem (at least not in my country). The second or third wife enter the marriage while knowing the existence of the first and the first wife accepted signing a marriage under the polygamy from the start
It is not an opinion. It is irrational but as long as it is consensual I dont really care. Pure hypocrisy though
HIKARU_GENJI:Lol. sadly your opinion doesn't matter