webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of MarcGem in Overlord: Supremacy of the Fallen

Review detail

MarcGem
MarcGemLv1311mthMarcGem

Every few months I come back to this novel...

altalt

Overlord: Supremacy of the Fallen

Protagonist_M

Liked by 1 people

LIKE

Replies2

MarcGem
MarcGemLv13MarcGem

No worries ! 1. I did not know about Daoism before reading these novels. My definition of Daoism has changed very frequently as I read more and more cultivation and xianxia works... After all, they're full of slaughter, violence, and harems hahaha. But after hundreds of novels, I think I know what it means. My definition (may be wrong idk) is: A way of life that people can follow to achieve a connection with nature and transcend into a higher being through a connection with a higher plane of existence, the Dao.I feel that a lot of novels do not really reflect the meaning of Daoism effectively. Here's examples of how they might incorporate or introduce Dao- Some of them have their MC drink poison and poison others to achieve the "Dao of poison", or kill others for the "Dao of slaughter."- Dao is mostly incorporated into cultivation itself, like drawing strength from nature (absorbing qi from the environment) and cultivating in serene settings. Or balancing violent energies to further their cultivation. - Striving to reach a higher plane of existence (and eventually immortality). Increasing in cultivation, essentially.- Having inner demons or heart demons which are obstacles to a calm state of mind- Contemplation. The MC rambles about Dao and enlightenment. But most times it just has a lot of grand words that frankly, don't make sense. Eg. Sword strikes with the force of fate, shattering illusions of reality. Within chaos, the silent whisper of Dao beckons. I feel that only one novel so far has been very clear in explaining the Dao in relation to its fictional universe and our society. Yet it has probably mentioned the word "Dao" only a handful of times. The novel is Reverend Insanity. It excels at outlining the relationship between man and heaven, exploring themes such as fate, morality, sacrifice, duality, power, etc. Most importantly it does so in a logical way that makes sense. I guess that's one of the reasons why it's touted as the best cultivation novel lol2. I come from a religious background, so maybe Dao can be equated to God? After all they're both a higher, transcendental reality. Both Daoism and Catholicism encourages a deeper understanding of this reality, and to align your life with its principles. Both have an emphasis on inner growth, detachment from material desires, balance and harmony. All in all, I believe that Daoism is quite similar to my culture. 3. Ah I'm planning a cultivation novel so I believe I have a good idea about those. I haven't researched about them tho, I'm just basing it off my reading experience. Tho I'm not incorporating the 5 elements. Anyway, here's what I think they are...Yin and Yang: Opposing forces of nature. Hot and cold, light and darkness etc. Men have more Yang energy with a little bit of yin, women the opposite. Like the Yin Yang symbol.Five elements: Wood represents growth, earth for stability etc. That's kind of all I know lolQi: Basically life force or energy, a fundamental thing that flows through all existence. The balance of Qi is crucial for wellbeing. Most cultivation novels utilise Qi so the majority of ppl should know what it is. Yin and Yang are also explained a lot, typically having to do with dual cultivation practices lol, or opposing energies such as a flower with intense flame qi growing next to a cold lake. But five elements are rarely explained. They're present in a lot of novels but they appear in those fancy phrases that don't make sense haha4. Reading cultivation novels definitely can pique interest in Chinese culture due to how different it is to their own, and serve as gateways to learning more about Chinese culture. But personally, I dread reading about how authors incorporate Chinese culture bc most cultivation novels only do it for the sake of including it, and not for the sake of creating a good story. But I think if I hadn't already read hundreds of novels, I'd find it quite novel and interesting as legitimate world-building, and not a copy paste setting that authors use.5. I use Reddit! There's lots of communities out there that revolves around Xianxia! I'm only in one though: Progression Fantasy. Subreddits are a very good place to gather opinions and material for your research! I kind of forgot to recommend it to you hahah. Because commenting individual people on webnovel is kind of low-reward compared to creating posts. If the subreddit has enough people, you can receive hundreds of comments in a day!

ningmeng:Really really appreciated for your so many words~it's very helpful. yeah, my thesis mainly focus on the cultivations, to know how foreign readers understand the " Daoism ". I see that your signature is about xianxia. so I have some further questions : 1. before reading cultivations, did you know about "Dao" or " Daoism "?Do the novels help you better understand "Dao" or " Daoism "?or do you think the novels you read reflect the values about "Daosim"? 2.how do you understand the the meaning of "Dao",or do you think the Chinese " Daoism " is different from your local cultrure?such as it delivers the values about the relationship between human and heaven . 3 I see you're a writer, so do you write something about the cultivation systems like the Chinese novels. or can you actually understand the Chinese culture such as ""Yin Yang", "Five Elements", and "Qi"? 4.can reading Chinese novels can stimulate your interest in Chinese traditional culture? 5.do you know some chat groups for Daoist, or how do you communicate the xianxia world with other. hahah~so many questions ~and thanks again ,anticipating for your reply. Best wishes!
ningmeng
ningmengLv1ningmeng

Hello! Very nice to meet you here! I am Joey, a Chinese student. Now I'm working on my thesis of Chinese web novels and foreign readers.To better understand the spread of Chinese web novels overseas ,I come here beeeeeging for your help. I wanna to know what do you think of them, and why you like to read. There is no private message function here, I can only contact you through this way. If possible I would like to communicate with you briefly ,and it will not take up too much of your time.Looking forward to your reply .

ningmeng
ningmengLv1ningmeng

Really really appreciated for your so many words~it's very helpful. yeah, my thesis mainly focus on the cultivations, to know how foreign readers understand the " Daoism ". I see that your signature is about xianxia. so I have some further questions : 1. before reading cultivations, did you know about "Dao" or " Daoism "?Do the novels help you better understand "Dao" or " Daoism "?or do you think the novels you read reflect the values about "Daosim"? 2.how do you understand the the meaning of "Dao",or do you think the Chinese " Daoism " is different from your local cultrure?such as it delivers the values about the relationship between human and heaven . 3 I see you're a writer, so do you write something about the cultivation systems like the Chinese novels. or can you actually understand the Chinese culture such as ""Yin Yang", "Five Elements", and "Qi"? 4.can reading Chinese novels can stimulate your interest in Chinese traditional culture? 5.do you know some chat groups for Daoist, or how do you communicate the xianxia world with other. hahah~so many questions ~and thanks again ,anticipating for your reply. Best wishes!

The content has been deleted