webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of Sevennamed in HP: A Magical Journey [Complete]

Review detail

Sevennamed
SevennamedLv123yrSevennamed

There are a couple of things I really dislike about this story: I absolutely loathe transmigration with memory / identity loss tropes. I believe it's the lowest form of fanfiction. There's something very off about the sentence structure and grammar that makes this story uncomfortable to read. πŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘ŽπŸ‘Ž

altalt

HP: A Magical Journey [Complete]

FictionOnlyReader

Liked by 110 people

LIKE

Replies19

Avaritia_0010
Avaritia_0010Lv4Avaritia_0010

did you even try reading 5 chapters or did you read 1 den criticize the story just because you don't like transmigration

Sevennamed
SevennamedLv12Sevennamed

Did you even read my review before you commented on it?

Avaritia_0010:did you even try reading 5 chapters or did you read 1 den criticize the story just because you don't like transmigration
Avaritia_0010
Avaritia_0010Lv4Avaritia_0010

yep

Sevennamed:Did you even read my review before you commented on it?
peter_spindler
peter_spindlerLv13peter_spindler

ok so you don't like transmigration with memory/personality loss. I can actually get that, but the grammar thing I don't understand, you gotta elaborate. if you can't I implore you to raise the rating at least by a half

Sevennamed
SevennamedLv12Sevennamed

Reading a story is like listening to music the sentences should flow together into the paragraphs in the paragraphs into the chapter. Reading this was like a listening to a radio that was jumping between stations every few seconds.

peter_spindler:ok so you don't like transmigration with memory/personality loss. I can actually get that, but the grammar thing I don't understand, you gotta elaborate. if you can't I implore you to raise the rating at least by a half
peter_spindler
peter_spindlerLv13peter_spindler

I see, i don't agree but that's ok.

Sevennamed:Reading a story is like listening to music the sentences should flow together into the paragraphs in the paragraphs into the chapter. Reading this was like a listening to a radio that was jumping between stations every few seconds.
T0xicity
T0xicityLv14T0xicity

That’s actually an incredible metaphor for writing...

Sevennamed:Reading a story is like listening to music the sentences should flow together into the paragraphs in the paragraphs into the chapter. Reading this was like a listening to a radio that was jumping between stations every few seconds.
Snooozer
SnooozerLv2Snooozer

Yeah,it feels like a poorly done translation where the words get translated to english but not the the "structure".

FastestOfAllSperm
FastestOfAllSpermLv2FastestOfAllSperm

DaoOfCookies
DaoOfCookiesLv4DaoOfCookies

Then just don't read it, that solves everything...

Noel_Elitia
Noel_ElitiaLv1Noel_Elitia

try reading when i got reincarnated as a spider with my goddess you won't be disappointed

ScorpiusMalfoy1981
ScorpiusMalfoy1981Lv4ScorpiusMalfoy1981

Each fanfiction has a different story, why are you even reading the story if you do not like the main idea of the story. Also don't review without reading all chapters.

Notacatowner
NotacatownerLv1Notacatowner

I personally feel that the grammar is near-perfect, but whatever you say...

White_Sami
White_SamiLv12White_Sami

It's kinda weird you go around telling people to read you own novel/fanfic without saying you are the author

Noel_Elitia:try reading when i got reincarnated as a spider with my goddess you won't be disappointed
mysteriousoldman
mysteriousoldmanLv2mysteriousoldman

not faster than me

FastestOfAllSperm:
image
QueLeo
QueLeoLv1QueLeo

The title already disgusted me

Noel_Elitia:try reading when i got reincarnated as a spider with my goddess you won't be disappointed
NiceReviewer
NiceReviewerLv4NiceReviewer

Kind of unfair to give him the lowest rating just because you don't like a particular trope. Also his English is extremely good... especially compared to yours. So kindly delete this review.

NiceReviewer
NiceReviewerLv4NiceReviewer

It's hilarious listening to this guy complaining about sentence structure and grammar. It's like a mutant who has 7 fingers complaining about gloves for people. Sure they don't fit you but you shouldn't judge things in the first place just because you are very different from other people.

BenisBoy14
BenisBoy14Lv13BenisBoy14

I'm 6 chapters in and the writing quality is atrocious. Some paragraphs are written by a 5 year old who hasn't figured out pronouns yet. Like, fr fr. If you have a page-long paragraph and it keeps talking about the MC, then it doesn't need to contain the name 50 times. Once is enough.