webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of VictorRust2410 in Reincarnated as Poseidon

Review detail

VictorRust2410
VictorRust2410Lv23yrVictorRust2410

A fanfic with a lot of potential but suffering from an inexperienced author. the starting chapters could be a bit boring and immaturish, especially for someone who've already read PJ series. Our MCs presence doesn't change anything much and you might get frustrated by how passive he seems. But the fic really takes off after Kronos's death. The mc starts changing things and differs from canon Poseidon. this is where i felt like i was finally reading about a SI posiedon changing the future instead of history just repeating itself without any changes. it improves a lot as a fic when si starts making waves. In short i like this fic and would be following its progress closely. I would've loved to give it a 4-4.5 but unfortunately that would be a false review. as i said earlier, the author is inexperienced and doesn't seem like a native English speaker and you can see that in the writing. it's still better than most of the crap on this site. Plus he can only improve as he gets experienced. all in all, not a masterpiece by any rights but still a great attempt at writing and a fanfic with a lot of potential and room for improvement. hopefully it won't be dropped.

altalt

Reincarnated as Poseidon

AfricanProdigy14

Liked by 11 people

LIKE

Replies8

AfricanProdigy14
AfricanProdigy14AuthorAfricanProdigy14

But i am a native english speaker?

AfricanProdigy14
AfricanProdigy14AuthorAfricanProdigy14

Thank you, i will try and improve

VictorRust2410
VictorRust2410Lv2VictorRust2410

Ah, sorry for assuming. there were a few grammatical mistakes though, so maybe a proofreader would be useful. or one of those online sites to check for any mistakes.

AfricanProdigy14:But i am a native english speaker?
AfricanProdigy14
AfricanProdigy14AuthorAfricanProdigy14

I’m only in eighth grade

VictorRust2410:Ah, sorry for assuming. there were a few grammatical mistakes though, so maybe a proofreader would be useful. or one of those online sites to check for any mistakes.
AfricanProdigy14
AfricanProdigy14AuthorAfricanProdigy14

But ill be glad to check out any sites for that, dont think my parents will pay fir that tho

VictorRust2410:Ah, sorry for assuming. there were a few grammatical mistakes though, so maybe a proofreader would be useful. or one of those online sites to check for any mistakes.
VictorRust2410
VictorRust2410Lv2VictorRust2410

yeah your name kinda gave it away lol. but anyway, this is a really great fic for your age, and don't let any haters force you to drop it. as i said, you aren't a bad author, just inexperienced and that'll be easily fixed with time. you can only improve as you continue to write afterall.

AfricanProdigy14:I’m only in eighth grade
VictorRust2410
VictorRust2410Lv2VictorRust2410

nah no need for that. i dont know about any cause i never check it. i just assumed it was free cause a lot of comments seem to advise that to authors.

AfricanProdigy14:But ill be glad to check out any sites for that, dont think my parents will pay fir that tho
image
H_Alex
H_AlexLv6H_Alex

You can use the free version of Grammarly.

AfricanProdigy14:But ill be glad to check out any sites for that, dont think my parents will pay fir that tho
image