webnovel

Review Detail of kouk2002 in Dark Wolf- Naruto Fanfic

Review detail

kouk2002
kouk2002Lv113yrkouk2002

First a little about my ratings. As a fanfic set in a preexisting world I can't give full marks for world background, as the author of the fic didn't create it. The author has added a few additions though so instead of a 3 I gave it a 4 for making his mark on it. I won't give a 5 in a fanfic set in the world of another author. The updates while frequent aren't scheduled coming seemingly whenever the author had the time. It could be a couple a day or a couple of days in-between. I gave a 4 for the fast frequent updates but won't give a 5 without updates being scheduled as well, so the readers know what and when to expect chapters. Writing is generally good, but not without mistakes, and it has to be basically perfect to get a 5 from me. Now story and character both got a 5 because the author put the effort to make it unique (personal experience and opinion). That is the basic reasoning, next, I will go more into details of it. The MC is an OC with new powers and abilities. It is quite complex and certainly frustrating at the start but gradually details are being revealed and we begin to understand how his power works and reasons for our frustrations. I currently look forward to seeing more about it in future chapters. At least at the moment, he could already be called OP aside from a few old monsters and the main players of the world he can fight the rest already and has a path likely to take him to the top of the world in the future. I do love that we are seeing a fanfic not set in team 7! How refreshing! Well, jokes aside it really is nice to see and it does make you wonder how certain teams came to be effective and well bonded when the characters within them are so different and problematic. The original never really explain it, so stories like this are good as they make you think about it while the authors come up with ways to make them work. Although it was a large source of my frustrations I appreciate the effort of giving the MC a unique background and history. Glad I made it through as I expect many may drop it during that period. The setting may have been better suited to an original novel than a fanfic where people come with different expectations. Usually about an OP MC maybe with a skimmed over tragic backstory before rising to the top while collecting beauties and face-slapping. I expect many will complain about the pairing that seems to be budding when it is not one of the main girls people usually choose unless it is a collect them all harem in which case she would be an afterthought. Though I am enjoying it as the relationship is growing slowly, sure some parts are a little forced to introduce things but that can't really be helped. With an OC character and the plot as it was, some meetings need to be forced so things can develop. I only have one complaint at this point that doesn't seem like it will resolve itself in time and that is his relationship with Kurenai. The start was understandable but currently, I see no reason for why the MC has to be subjected to her whims and violence. It just seemed to happen all of a sudden with no real reason behind it. MC should be basically as strong as her or rather in most aspects he should be superior, just with his circumstances will be in a lower-ranking position, something she should know at least the basics of. I can't think of any reason why since she knows his issues are something he can't just recover from, it is impossible based on what we (and Kurenai) currently know. If it was supposed to be some kind of banter, it failed to come across as such to me. So I can only hope the author will explain why things became like that between them.

Dark Wolf- Naruto Fanfic

DaoistlvsgQ6

Liked by 19 people

LIKE

Replies11

MkGod
MkGodLv14MkGod

A proper review.. Finally.

David_Philyaw_4663
David_Philyaw_4663Lv14David_Philyaw_4663

Well I really think that you should not be to harsh on the story and the author just try to be a bit better to him after all he is writing stories for our entertainment

kouk2002
kouk2002Lv11kouk2002

If you say so, though I'm not sure how I was harsh, the overall rating was quite high as was my enjoyment once I got past the difficult parts of the MC's past. You have to consider this is a fanfic on Webnovel so the comments for creating such a setting can be quite abusive, to say the least. Had it been quick to move on with the story it would be easier for the reader to accept but it did not. Readers of a fanfic set in Naruto aren't there for the drama, most will simply want an OP MC who messes with the plot and characters whilst collecting harem members or in other words, a happy go lucky wish fulfilment fantasy. I believe I was pointing out that it was a setting that may have been better appreciated outside of a fanfic. In my opinion, I explained how and why I gave the ratings I did. I believe I did it fairly and gave credit where it's due. I see way too many reviews, where the reviewer ignores the criteria upon which they should be making judgements. Where release is given 0 even though the author releases daily or worse 3 or 4 chapters a day and still got 0, simply because the reviewer didn't like what they read or the attitude of the author to criticism. Then there are the stupid reviews repeating XP and the like, that don't help potential readers and certainly don't help the author.

David_Philyaw_4663:Well I really think that you should not be to harsh on the story and the author just try to be a bit better to him after all he is writing stories for our entertainment
Arny
ArnyLv15Arny

« I wont give a 5 in a fanfic set in the world of another author » Isn’t it the point of a fanfiction to use the world of fiction written by the original author ? Or I don’t understand your point ? Please enlighten me !

kouk2002
kouk2002Lv11kouk2002

Fanfiction is based on using someone else's ideas for your own story. That could be characters, powers, settings, world or anything else that belongs to someone else. So basically even if it wasn't set in Naruto and the Elemental nations it would still be a fanfic even if they only used something like Shadow Clones.

Arny:« I wont give a 5 in a fanfic set in the world of another author » Isn’t it the point of a fanfiction to use the world of fiction written by the original author ? Or I don’t understand your point ? Please enlighten me !
Arny
ArnyLv15Arny

I understand, but I didn’t understand the fact of not giving a 5 star on the world building category just because he used the world of another author. I mean, every fanfic use the world of another author, so you never give a 5 star in the world building category to anyone writing a fanfic ?

kouk2002:Fanfiction is based on using someone else's ideas for your own story. That could be characters, powers, settings, world or anything else that belongs to someone else. So basically even if it wasn't set in Naruto and the Elemental nations it would still be a fanfic even if they only used something like Shadow Clones.
kouk2002
kouk2002Lv11kouk2002

I can't say I haven't but when I have the fanfic author either created their own world or merged and added so many new things that it was no longer the world of the original author. I take it that the rating is asking how well the author of the novel I am reading did, not the author they based the work on. If the author of the work I'm reading didn't create the world the novel is set in, why should I give them full marks for it? Another way to put is it is like doing your homework but having copied everything from Wikipedia. Sure it may be correct but it does not show your effort and understanding of the subject so of course you will be marked down for it.

Arny:I understand, but I didn’t understand the fact of not giving a 5 star on the world building category just because he used the world of another author. I mean, every fanfic use the world of another author, so you never give a 5 star in the world building category to anyone writing a fanfic ?
Arny
ArnyLv15Arny

Ye I agree with you now, I just didn’t understand before, so I was just casually asking. Have a good night :)

kouk2002:I can't say I haven't but when I have the fanfic author either created their own world or merged and added so many new things that it was no longer the world of the original author. I take it that the rating is asking how well the author of the novel I am reading did, not the author they based the work on. If the author of the work I'm reading didn't create the world the novel is set in, why should I give them full marks for it? Another way to put is it is like doing your homework but having copied everything from Wikipedia. Sure it may be correct but it does not show your effort and understanding of the subject so of course you will be marked down for it.
Ttsfih
TtsfihLv4Ttsfih

Who is love interest of mc?

kouk2002
kouk2002Lv11kouk2002

<spoiler>It was shaping up to suggest Tenten, though MC in the latest chapter seems to reject it as he doesn't believe he is worthy of love.</spoiler>

Ttsfih:Who is love interest of mc?
DragonkingKyo
DragonkingKyoLv6DragonkingKyo

Ahh to bad I was hoping for hinata.

kouk2002:<spoiler>It was shaping up to suggest Tenten, though MC in the latest chapter seems to reject it as he doesn't believe he is worthy of love.</spoiler>