webnovel

Review Detail of sumwale in My Disciples Are All Villains

Review detail

sumwale
sumwaleLv143yrsumwale

Overall a good cultivation novel, quite refreshingly different from the usual run of the mill ones. Will definitely recommend others to read through at least 20-30 chapters before forming Adm opinion. Unlike what the title suggests, the master and disciples are really not that villainous in the story so far (which is really refreshing). I have a couple of gripes though. The primary being that we do not get to know the mind of the transmigrant MC. All we see is the MC playing the role of 'old villain' (whose body he occupies) as best as he can. But it's really a stretch to imply that this is really what he wants to do especially for someone coming from modern earth. Somehow the MC totally adopts the role as his own in an instant (though the disciples do say that he has mellowed down from before) and we never get to see what the MC himself wants to achieve. Secondly there are hardly any normal conversations with the MC. Others are kneeling before him most of the time, including his disciples who he is either reprimanding or ordering. While this may be the norm in that world but it is quite strange to see MC adapting to this in a heartbeat coming from modern earth. Likewise it is quite strange to see MC show anger eruption from so-called 'betrayal' by some of his disciples when he should have no sense of master-disciple relation despite inheriting some of the memories.

My Disciples Are All Villains

MSRZP

Liked by 2 people

LIKE

Replies3

21man
21manLv1521man

does it get better or is the same all through the novel

21man
21manLv1521man

so does it get better how he does his disciples

sumwale
sumwaleLv14sumwale

Story and situations are very interesting and unique in this novel. Largely because focus is not tiresome endless 'cultivation' through unending levels as MC is already the strongest overall with the cheats. So at least as of now the focus is on other off-beat plots (e.g. 'disciplining' his 'rogue' disciples). So overall I would wholly recommend this novel despite the two issues I mentioned. Those were highlighted primarily as feedback to the author to further improve.