webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of Xylade in

Review detail

Xylade
XyladeLv43yrXylade

TIA: "I'm gonna change my fate" Ending: Still ends up with the prince Let's just be frank.. Tia only reincarnated so that she can be a better fit for the prince... Its basically saying that Tia's misfortune in the first timeline is because she is not good enough and she deserves to die and not loved This manhwa is wrong in so many levels. And the authors attachment to the prince character as the ML is just plain sick.. Its basically saying that even if the prince is rotten it doesn't matter cause he is royalty... This story is CRAP.

altalt

Liked by 46 people

LIKE

Replies8

KITCHEN_FRENZY
KITCHEN_FRENZYLv1KITCHEN_FRENZY

I couldn't agree with you more.

Nohra
NohraLv4Nohra

I was only reading this novel because Carsein's character was extremely lovable, I seriously hoped for him to get together with Tia. But she was only a dumb, blind little girl.

mystery_magic
mystery_magicLv4mystery_magic

I am totally sick of this masochistic stories. Authors are really becoming sadists i guess🤨

I_Am_Groot_5467
I_Am_Groot_5467Lv1I_Am_Groot_5467

You have yet to give a valid reasoning though lol. Literally, just take your time and read and maybe you'd understand a but more. Her reasoning was actually pretty valid, and it even states that she wants the love of the Prince in the description. Another thing is you cannot help who you love, which also comes into play. And his backstory, was pretty well written and honestly understandable. She wasn't such a great character either.

Xylade
XyladeLv4Xylade

You see the problem with these type of stories where the protagonist goes back to the past and in the end, still ends up with her past abuser with the excuse of "he's changed, he's not the same person as he was in the past" is that it romanticizes past trauma, toxic relationships, and abusive behavior which is not and will never be a good reading material. Your pain or even a drug, although explains it, is never an excuse to abuse another. Moreover, the characters don't feel real at all, they just serve as a plot device so the audience's sympathy would fall on the female protagonist. Having side characters as a plot device isn't a bad thing yes but your main cast shouldn't just serve as some plot device, sadly in this case, they do. While we don't blame the characters for turning into what they are, it is ultimately the author's fault. Stories involving emotional abuse and healing over it takes a lot of emotional maturity. If the author intended for Ruve and Tia to end up together, she shouldn't have made him Tia's abuser. As a writer, you have the responsibility to take proper care of the themes you want to portray in order to not send the wrong message to your audience. Stories shape worldviews, folks. So I caution you, only read this if you want an example of what bad writing is, how you shouldn't romanticize certain things, how the characters only serve as a plot device for the protagonist, and how the author failed to deliver her story's chosen themes properly.

I_Am_Groot_5467:You have yet to give a valid reasoning though lol. Literally, just take your time and read and maybe you'd understand a but more. Her reasoning was actually pretty valid, and it even states that she wants the love of the Prince in the description. Another thing is you cannot help who you love, which also comes into play. And his backstory, was pretty well written and honestly understandable. She wasn't such a great character either.
amdius
amdiusLv3amdius

unfortunately you are right 😔✋🏻. i couldn't agree more 🔪

Andreas_karlsson
Andreas_karlssonLv10Andreas_karlsson

youre ubderselling the vileness of the prince by calling him rotten. by far the worst villain ive read in a shoujo romance.

Melody_3044
Melody_3044Lv13Melody_3044

Thanks for this honest review! You saved me from reading something that would have left me enraged!