webnovel
avatar

Review Detail of PxFive in The Intelligent Potter

Review detail

PxFive
PxFiveAuthor4yrPxFive

Okay, this is my best attempt at being objective about my own work. For those of you who don't know/ haven't figured it out, The Intelligent Potter is a work I started writing over 3 years ago, over on FanFiction.Net, and I was a much different writer then than I am now, and I've got to say that I've gotten a LOT better at writing than I used to be. TIP was my first shot at a 100k+ word story of any kind, and since I started, I've taken part in 2 NNWMs, and written one other novel-length piece as well. My writing has gotten a lot better, in the last fifty chapters than it was in the first thirty or so. The quality of writing, I would say, is simple and casual, but fairly engaging. It suffers from some repetition, and falls into the trap of too many adverbs to try and give meaning, which are sometimes not requires. As well as this, details are sometimes sparse, and I have been told before that I write a little bit barebones. However, my writing is also enjoyed by a lot of readers, and is a fairly good style, I think. The story is very well structured, and I am very happy with how it is turning out. There are fairly regular cliffhangers and I tackle a lot of things in new and innovative ways. I use some tropes, but I turn others completely on their heads. I promise you will not see everything coming. I have fleshed out the world a fair bit in some chapters as well, and I think it is better than Rowling's own worldbuilding at the least, though it has the least worldbuilding out of my own personal projects. Overall, I would say that 'The Intelligent Potter' is definitely worth the read, if you're willing to bear with the writing near the beginning, and enjoy plot and characters and awesomeness more than flowery and beautiful writing.

altalt

The Intelligent Potter

PxFive

Liked by 22 people

LIKE

Replies9

NorthernWind
NorthernWindLv10NorthernWind

Rowling's world building is mediocre.

DarkKnight32
DarkKnight32Lv6DarkKnight32

Dude you should have not just posted wvwry chapter thats a not good way to earn readers especially if you are not posting daily would recommend you to post 2 to 3 chapters a day this would bring a huge readers base

SD_Liv
SD_LivLv4SD_Liv

Harem?

PxFive
PxFiveAuthorPxFive

if the complete lack of any setup in almost one hundred characters hasn't tipped you off, no harem.

SD_Liv:Harem?
SD_Liv
SD_LivLv4SD_Liv

thanks for the answer

PxFive:if the complete lack of any setup in almost one hundred characters hasn't tipped you off, no harem.
asaade_ragnarokm
asaade_ragnarokmLv4asaade_ragnarokm

looks like an edited canon same plot same storyline, aside from that you're making a script not a novel example scene 1 in the corridor you will talk with hermione and then cut scene 2 you and hermione will be in the library and talk there and cut scene 3 hagrids hut you will with hagrid along with hermione and cut scene 4 already inside the castle you will with hermione about hagrid you are making a facking script not a novel, the flow of the story is nowhere to be found you cut the story and skipped to the next part that's how a script is

shashank_bhatt
shashank_bhattLv14shashank_bhatt

FL is Hermione Granger!?

PxFive:if the complete lack of any setup in almost one hundred characters hasn't tipped you off, no harem.
noobageddon_
noobageddon_Lv13noobageddon_

Lol, when i saw the tags and theres pxfive in it. I was like’whats that’ and like search it for 5min. Lol and when theres no result, I decide to ask the author im the review section. But then, i saw author’s name...

injured
injuredLv2injured

lol

SD_Liv:Harem?