Complex novel yet has 0 loopholes The contents of previous chapters will keep popping up in new chapter so u should hve good memory The first 20 chapters shows us how cruel the cultivation world is and kind off gives us an impression that MC is an edgelord .But he is clearly not he is just surviving . The pacing is super smooth and there are no honestly up and downs for this novel except a few may think the starting is a bit awkward but i believe it is required coz he has good amount of character development . Mainly it's like he has an increase of confidence along with strength so he would be less paranoid. The MC is smart intelligent and this shows throughout the novel . MC is creative and innovative and he takes ideas from his experiences unlike other novel where there are no explanation given how MC created techniques . SIDE CHARACTER are not just stepping stones meant for mc (there are no cliche character) they have there own character development and good amount of screen time and more importantly most of the characters are not leeches that suck upon mc wealth. THE STORY is well written the amount of foresight the author has used from the first chapter till recent is mind-blowing , the most amazing this about this novel is it's UNPREDICTABLE ,UNQUIE so it will always keep you on your toes to know "WHAT HAPPENED NEXT!!?" . CULTIVATION SYSTEM IS UNQUIE ,each phase and has its own attributes and challenges (most other cultivation novels there are only lightning tribulations) ,MC IS BASICALLY CREATING HIS OWN PATH OF CULTIVATION WITHOUT FOLLOWING SOMEONE ELSE LEGACY. ALCHEMY SYSTEM , alchemy is really well explained and logical . There are a lot of division in pills , potion , material in form of grade tiers , quality etc . ALCHEMY itself has lvls and conditions for breakthrough to next stage. Formation , tailsman , armament , weapons etc have not been given much information about . The WORLD BUILDING is actually quite common , it has elves , demons , hybrids etc but this is just about races the actual world building like places for example they are continents , planets , stellar region , domains ,zones etc have there own history along with info about the rulers , more organization will be introduced along with time ( ex , clan's , sect , pavillion etc). THE DISCRIPTION OF PEOPLE AND ENVIRONMENT are really easy so u can imagine them quite easily . ITS A MASTERPIECE FOR SURE JUST BE PATIENT FOR FEW FIRST FEW CHAPTERS BECAUSE THE MC IS ALREADY A CORE DISCIPLE ,SO THIS STORY IS NOT WEAK TO STRONG INSTEAD ITS STRONG TO SUPER STRONG . A SLIGHT SPOILER IS THAT MC IS SIMILAR TO A MOB CHARACTER WHERE HE FIGHTS WITH DIFFERENT MC S AND THERE IS SOMETHING CALLED HEAVENLY DAOS THAT CONTROL ONES FATE AND MC IS TASKED TO FIGHT AGAINST IT.

I m telling this bcoz if u guys remember . When he first met the black skeleton long Chen was mentioned as black clothes youth who kills WW. After reading many more chapters long Chen stills did not make an appearance , i thought why did the author mentioned thim as black clothed youth if he would not make an appearance at all. Only after end of the myriad yore continent arc did long Chen make appearance (when he sensed quing quimu's aura and confused it for that bit*h who tried assassinating him at the start ) he met long Chen alongside quingquimu.

Do u guys remember chapter where the evil cultivator failed to ascend and WW saw his x lover in that small village ? .Her appearance was abrupt and doesn't even serve the role in of side character. I wonder if she would make reappearnce as a blessed . Sinc WW is 49 old , she should be in her mid 50 s . She should hv not yet died . I hope she makes an reappearance as blessed or else why was she even introduced ? .

Can the author tell me what happened to dushan ( his servant at the beginning and he left him scarlet Solaris sect ) . He should also be in grand cyclic region right? Since everyone was pulled by world shifting net .

You reminded me of the quote " one's terrorist someone else's freedom fighters fighter"

And what happened to dushan (his servant at beginning of the novel ) since he too would be brought by world shifting net to grand cyclic stellar region .

It's sad that you are not getting much exposture , i really love your novel , it's so complex yet without loopholes. Everything is well explained . Sometimes I thought some things were forced and made sudden appearance but after reading futher everything started making sense. Like a spiderweb everything connects with each other perfectly whithout loop holes. I honestly in depression after finishing all your chapters like i have nothing to do but wait for next chapter , that's how much good the novel is , i can't believe you are same creator of 'swallowing heaven and earth ' when I first read that novel i was quite dissatisfied even felt the author is a noob 12 year old but after reading Paragon of sin i was dumbfounded can't believe you are the same guy , but that also makes sense, you created that novel 3 years ago and this 1 .4 year ago which means u hv improved in your writing to a godly lvl in this period of time . Just the amount of foresight and planning you have done in this novel are out of the world. If only you had better cover art you would have more readers also the first few chapters there are a ton of fast developments and the story starts abruptly in middle of something , the mission to erase violet moon sect . I also understand that you couldn't start the story from Wei wuyin s childhood since that would probably be a crucial in the later of the novel . But most people would become confused and disinterested and give such masterpiece at the start itself , infact i myself felt that i should skip the novel . But the writing felt different for me so I took a chance , later I the 'different' became ' unique ' , 'unique ' became masterpiece ' , 'masterpiece ' became 'my best read till now ' and i doubt i would ever come across such a novel.

Spoilers . . . I guess she is an important side character and i find it natural for him to be attracted to a female (he has soft spot only for beautiful female , for example he spares yu fei in blood forge continent arc and spoils the entire plan for her ) after a long time without intercourse in world realm. I have read till recent chapter where I saw him freeing a female cultivator ( she is in 2nd stage of ascended) he basically came to save a slave(male) whom he got the info through mind reading a scammer ('young looking guy 'is the supposed name author refers him). That slave haf low level cultivation but an extremely high lvl intent . So after he saves the slave and her . He tells her that he will come back to her . So I can tell that Wei wuyin has soft corner for only BEAUTIFUL WOMEN of course he is by no means a simp or a playboy who goes behind every women . So I find it natural for him to kidnap the female elf since he is consistent in his character .

You mean San songli? ,( The foreshadowing chapter ?).