His secret

"Which means that you're a supernatural being too, aren't you?" she asked him. It was strange hearing herself say that. 

Years ago, she would've laughed at herself for asking such a weird question, but she was listening to her gut. 

After everything that had been happening and all of the information available to her, she couldn't ignore the thought.

Elias lowered his eyes from hers, almost looking ashamed.

"I would never hurt you," he promised her.

That was a good enough answer for Alyssa. 

If he wasn't a supernatural being, he would tell her no. She believed that they were past the point of hiding things from each other. 

When he wouldn't look back up at her, she placed a hand on his shoulder, drawing his eyes to hers.

"Care to tell me what you're? What type of supernatural being are you? A werewolf?"

Elias chuckled a little when he heard her. She was taking this information much better than he had expected.