Reviews of Reincarnated as a Son of the Sword Saint and the Sage

Honestly I want to like this novel. I really do. Like, I see the potential it has but theres just that one thing thats really bugging me. It's the fact that he is so... submissive. Now what do I mean by that? He's clearly a dork who has never had a girlfriend in his life. He's a simpleton who would likely give up all his powers if his mom, mother (He has two moms) and sister asked him to. In our everyday language he would definitely be a simp. I think the thing that really bugged me was him admitting his secret to his sister. I said it in a comment but I found the build up for him telling the secret to be plainly infuriating and terrible. Author, in the nicest way possible I want to tell you that it was bad. But the big kicker is the fact that although he has all this power his real personality is still so...wimpy. It's Honestly disappointing and I unfortunately will choose to drop this novel. If anyone else can stand a simpleton who acts like he's chasing skirts with the mind of a 30 year old man whose never been a women then feel free.

It's bad, the mc personality is submissive under his sister thumb, his attitude mimics typical japanese beta males with the "go-lucky attitude" with overpowered abilities.

I don't know why those LGBT idiots spread the word, God made them that way. If god really made them that way I don't know why he created eve in the first place.

Big question I haven’t started yet but I looks good. Will the moms be in the harem that would be amazing?

The MC is a deplorable and submissive S.I.M.P. There really is no reason for it and just seems to happen for gags and giggles, but it gets old really fast. The story also gets derailed often and many times where the mc could just say 'no' to bothersome stuff, he took it upon himself to say yes and whine about it. The simpening started around 23 ch.

He gives in way to much he like a dog his sister told him she wanted to put him on a leash and convince himself that it for a good reason he is weak minded he needs to be a man change that and he would be perfect

can you please fasten the story development and fixe the da*n MC mentality

Not to be that guy, but what happened to "my first time is reserved for Sophie".

will there be yuri in harem?....,.,.,.,.,.,.,..,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,..,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,..,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.,.

Huge amounts of info drops at the start and the writing quality could be better but overall a decent read.But i would prefer the mc to be less submissive to his sister.

everyone saying mc is a beta despite him being less than 15makes me wonder if they have brains, also all the painful waiting is worth it by chapter 100 when the best part begins

writing quality is just OK. There are mistakes character design leaves much to be desired. It's like the bare minimum story development is way too slow

I like the story so far but I belave their needs to be more stakes involved in the story like stronger enemies from the south and thier need to be threat like if x happens in the south enemies that are capable of harming MC become involved in the MC's life. otherwise I also beleave a battle taking more than 10 chapter is a bit overkill unless it involves different groups over a larger time scale otherwise it becomes a bit repetitive. it's a good story and I hope it become more flushed out and the MC gets into more smutty situations.

Great story so far and I like way the story is going

it's an "alternative" story focusing on the 3rd gender and focuses on the fantastical life of such family

Reveal spoiler

novel reallly good nice story development and world background just want to ask will his harem include his sister if not then please make her with Mary joining in it would be really nice

I find this story really very good, a development that advances characters that seem to exist, and above all we are not in a world where the mc must fight every day to save the world by not taking advantage of life, in any case for the moment. I understand criticizing her with respect to the servile Mc with his family but it's just because he adores them, his sister hasn't put a collar on his heart that I know of, right? to conclude very interesting story to see to judge.

one of kind novel and best of kind nice story

one of the novels that I like the most, please do not abandon it,cheer up[img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend]