7 Caught

"What?" I ask

Isabelle sat up straight before saying

"Do you want to put it in my pussy?" repearing what she said I was shock, immediately I said

"No, we can't, what if Isabella comes."

"I've locked the doors, so even if she comes, we have enough to hide any evidences that we're fucking the entire time"

"Still, wouldn't she get suspicious?"

"We can just come up of an excuse, can't we?"

"B-but..."

"Come on, I know you want this, don't deny it. Look your dick is still hard even though you've already came twice"

"..." I was speechless, I know we shouldn't do this, but I can't help wanting more, after all this could be my chance to do it with Isabelle. After a while she continued

"Alright fine, if you really don't want to do this, say to me that you don't want to fuck me, I want to know if you're really displeased with this, if you say it, I promise I'll stop" impatient with me, she said, eager to put it in

"..." even after sometime I couldn't say it, her straightforward request was my out to this, all I'd have to do is say a few words, yet I couldn't do it, why? Tired of waiting she smiled

"I'll take that as your answer, then"

"Wait!" not listening to she lifts herself up a bit and placed herself where my dick would go straight to her pussy. She lowers herself down, her panties touching my dick, she was teasing me by smearing my dick across her slit which could be felt from her lace panties, back and forth, as she continues to tease me she said

"You can't wait to be inside me, can you?" and slides her panties to the side, without anything to say I look away from her, she chuckles and said "Well, here we it comes."

*knock knock*

the sudden knocking surprised both of you, and causing her to stumble back

*knock knock*

as the knocking continues Isabelle said "I'll be right there" and proceeds to get dressed in casual clothing, putting her uniform in the bathroom connected to her bedroom, then she pulled up my clothes back, and coved me with a blanket. Walking to the door, she opened it and said "Yes?"

Outside the room was Isabella in casual clothing, she looked at me and smile

"Good afternoon, Aiko," before looking back at Isabelle, grabing her wrist and pulling her out the room "Hey!" Isabelle complained while being pulled, closing the door behind her. As you wait for Isabelle to come back, the door opened and, who you think is Isabelle came back

"Well lunch is ready, I guess we just have to continue later" she said sighing dejectedly, but immediately after she smiled and said

"But don't worry, I'll be the one feeding you, I hope you're hungry." She walks over to me and moved the blankets aside saying "It must be hot with this blanket on, here, let me move it for you" biting her lips while she move the blanket I looked away blushing "Are we really gonna continue?"

..."Isabelle?" after not hearing any response from her I curiously look back

*Slap!!!*

Shocked, my eyes widen, my cheek stinging from the slap.

I look back at her, her arms stretched down, and her hands clenched tightly, tears dropping from her eyes, sobbing.

"Isabel...la?" as realization struck me, I panicked

"Wait! Isabella, let me explain! We-"

"Shut up!" she was angry, yet sad at the same time. I kept quiet, not wanting to upset her even more, and knowing that whatever I say here, it would not help me, nor Isabelle's situation, letting her continue, she said "I knew *Sob* Isabelle *Sob* would do something, *Sob* but I thought, *Sob* I thought she wouldn't go beyond kissing! *Sob* But this..." Still crying, she rushed out of the room, her arm covering her eyes, the door slammed shut.

I felt incredibly guilty afterwards, although it wasn't me who started it, I still didn't refuse her.

After a several minutes pass, Sophie came in with a tray filled with food, after setting it down the bedside table, as she was sitting I ask in a sad tone

"Where is Isabella?"

"Both Isabella and Isabelle are eating lunch in the dinning hall"

"What happened?" I ask as though she knew what happened earlier

"When she came down, she was glaring right at Isabelle, which wasn't unusual, they never did get along, well not since they were kids, but I did notice her eyes were slightly red, and looking at the bed, I think I know why" feeling guilty I looked away

"Did their mother saw?"

"No, Mrs. Rosemarie isn't home"

"*Sigh* That's a relief"

"Anyway, Isabella asked me to feed you, so here." after I ate lunch, fed to me by sophie, I ask

her while she was tidying up the dishes

"Are you... mad at me, or something?"

"No, I am not. I am aware of the fact that Lady Isabelle was the one to take the lead, however, I am still disapointed at you for not being able to refuse Lady Isabelle's temptations."

Holding the tray with one hand, she started walking to the door, but before leaving, she sighed, and turn toward me

"I have a request"

"What is it?" I respond

"Can you talk to them. I will ask them to go here, so can you tell to go back to being caring to one another, and stop this quarrel between sisters about who gets to keep you for themselves. Since they love you, they should at least listen to you."

"Yes, I can do that."

"Thank you, I'll call the right away"

Sophie then left the room with the tray, and a few minutes later, Isabelle and Isabella both came into the room, glaring at each other, although I knew that they hated each other, I didn't know to what extent.

"Can you please stop this." both Isabelle and Isabella turned to me, and Isabelle responded

"Stop What!?"

"This! Why are you so mad at each other? Can't you just be friends?" Isabelle's eyes widen in anger

"Friends! you think I can be friends with her! She's the reason we're in this situation in the first place, if she hadn't gone through my phone, and pretended to be me, we'd be going on date by now!" Isabella got mad at Isabelle's statement and shouted at her

"Oh, so this is my fault! I'm not the one who kidnaped Aiko, and tied him up to the bed!"

"Stop! Please, Stop! We all did things that we shouldn't have done, so why don't we just-"

I tried to stop them, but Isabella cut me of mid-sentence

"Shut up, Aiko, don't even try to defend her, I know what I did was wrong, but she crossed the line, she kidnaped you, and she took you're first, which was suppose to be with me!" Isabelle then says to Isabella mockingly

"With you!? You teally think he would choose you over me!? I bet you couldn't even give him a proper blowjob! Besides we never really had sex, since someone suddenly showed up, and ruining the perfectly romantic mood I set up."

The two of them continued arguing, and mocking each until I spoke

"I'm Sorry."

Both Isabelle and Isabella we're confused, so they turn back at me and said "What?"

"It's my fault you are fighting like this" immediately after, Isabella said

"What!? No, it's not you're fault, if anything, it's her fault for going too far."

"No, if I had paid more attention to yours and Isabelle's feelings, this wouldn't have happened."

Isabelle then said

"It's not your fault for not realizing, that's just part of your charm." I then replied

"That's not charm, that's just an excuse."

Both Isabelle and Isabella got flustered, and after thinking for a bit, Isabella suggested

"I got it! You can choose which one of us you'll take as you're girlfriend!", but I replied

"I can't just choose which one will be my girlfriend, and no matter who I choose, the other person would end up extremely sad because of it, and I can't have that!"

"Then, how about the two of us, that way you wouldn't have to choose." Isabella tried to convince me, but I rejected that option saying

"That can't happen, I wouldn't be able to spend time with both of you, and you and Isabelle, wouldn't want it anyway."

"Since Aiko is so considerate, I decided to be considerate as well, Aiko will choose one of us, but..." after I finished my statement Isabelle finally thought of something. She formed a devilish smile and a murderous look, then said

"What if there was only one option."