Im just gonna say this, due to you adding Thalia to the harem, feel free to drop any of the originally planned girls if you dont like the idea of them anymore.
Im just saying this so you don't feel like you're writing yourself into a ditch trying to manage all the girls.
If this were a duel that could use his born abilities he could create his humanoid shadow soldiers and give them bows he would have an army of archers with him the hunters would lose quickly
