Comments of chapter undefined of Enchanting Melodies (HP SI)

Enchanting Melodies (HP SI)

athass_prkr

Chapter comments18

orstedssamaLv2orstedssama

I don't understand why they want to cause more problems for Harry, Lily protected him when he was a baby and I don't see why she suddenly wanted to kill him, maybe she didn't feel love for James but she did for Harry.Furthermore, he was not seen to have any reason to harm Harry, being in another dimension does not count since Lily is intelligent enough to know that Harry was a baby.

1mth

AlfiemooonLv4Alfiemooon

we don't actually know if she wants to harm harry in any way. She hasn't given us any indication she'll do so, However, she's allied with people who harry are antagonist against; if she does try to harm him, it would be because of those allies.

1mth

View 1 reply

Raptor2244Lv13Raptor2244

I’m enjoying the multiple plots youre weaving very much. I still think that despite Harry being strong for his age, he needs to power up substantially or he’s going to die. He stands no chance against the likes of Voldemort, grindenwald, dumbledore and lily in any kind of head on confrontation.

1mth

View 1 reply

I'm waiting for you on the app's discussion channel!

Download the app to discuss your favorite works, TV shows, and even the weather with me!

athass_prkr

watzJLv4watzJ

All this, of course, is interesting to read, but I can’t shake the feeling that Harry is ceasing to be an MC. Probably too many side stories at once does this... tftc

1mth

THEL0SE4Lv4THEL0SE4

i love the gray and more human characters, the ones where you can see and, to an extent, relate. I hope Lily doesn't turn out to be purely(comically) evil. even if she somehow(from Harry's pov) becomes an "antagonist/big bad guy," hopefully we get to see who she actually is in this story because the build-up up to this point was great. if that made sense, idk. THANKS FOR THE CHAPTER 🙏 ps: i wonder how Harry's "magic sense" compares to Lily's. If that is what she used in the elevator in the first place. It sounded like it was.

1mth

View 2 Replies

Hell_HopeLv3Hell_Hope

Thanks for the chapter

1mth

WasadLv5Wasad

Thanks for the chapter.

1mth

AlfiemooonLv4Alfiemooon

I hope harry keeps lily away from him. We really don't need a "bad parent not really bad, eventually dies to save child" trope. it's way too cliche and lily would serve much better as a constant villain.

1mth