webnovel
avatar

Comments of chapter undefined of Enchanting Melodies (HP SI)

Abyss_123
Abyss_123Lv13Abyss_123

TFTC!

DaoistxjRjqE
DaoistxjRjqELv1DaoistxjRjqE

Save her. Look, Hermione is in an Ideal World, in heaven, so to speak, and then she wakes up and realizes it’s all a deception. Quite a cruel event for a little bookworm, but this girl from Gryffindor itself, not Ravenclaw, will only have the choice to stand up and change this corrupt world. This will give more weight to the future and cannon desire to become a Master of Magic.

AnteChao
AnteChaoLv14AnteChao

Just kill off Hermiome to make Neville mature just a tiny bit, especially after what the MC said to him at the end there. Frankly if you decide to save her for whatever reason, then atleast make it so she ain't important to the story. Because we still see and hear too much of her... Then again I don't like Hermione at all in any story, so definitely a biased opinion lol. Some people have suggested for the MC to save her, and what get on Dumbledores radar again or others radar, like in my opinion she is in a way brain dead but is able to live her life in a dream world. So either kill her off or keep her as a vegetable and as a reminder for Neville. Also I still don't understand why the MC is still hung up on her, she chose to leave their friendship and he feels bad and all......

DEATHS_SHADOW07
DEATHS_SHADOW07Lv4DEATHS_SHADOW07

chapter should have been called gaslighting Neville 😂

DIMIE_21
DIMIE_21Lv4DIMIE_21

Please if your going to kill anyone let it be Ron because anything done to her at this point is going to be torture for an innocent character who just made a mistake and wanted her friend back

Jakub_Sobieraj
Jakub_SobierajLv1Jakub_Sobieraj

Save Hermione!!!

_Solomon_
_Solomon_Lv4_Solomon_

Honestly Neville went overboard here like during the chamber of secrets he did not hesitate to attack Harry to save Hermione(supposedly), yet now that no one's believing his story he rages which just goes to show that although he might care for his friends and others generally his fame as the BWL and saviour and much are more important and I'd say that he's insecure of himself while comparing himself to Harry and thinks that everything he has now is due to his status as the saviour and not because he is Neville...But this also gives us a chance to look at Neville's character development into someone more confident and more original

KissMyGloriousAxe
KissMyGloriousAxeLv13KissMyGloriousAxe

Kill her, Longbottom needs the full wakeup call package. That's what Sirius was to Harry. Alternatively, have her wake up but with several years passing in the diary. Have her new mature outlook give Harry the rival; and friend he truly needs.

Everton_Azevedo
Everton_AzevedoLv1Everton_Azevedo

Sou da opinião que Hermione deve ser salva. Para mim todo esse arco serviu para mostra as falhas de Harry, sua passividade diante dos acontecimentos, como se ele fosse um observador externo quando ele é apenas mais ator da peça que está se desenrolando, sua arrogância nascida da sua grande capacidade que o fez subestimar os oponentes. E agora temos um incrível dilema moral que com certeza repecutira no futuro de Harry. Para que o mal vença basta que os bons não façam nada.

Kishore_Dhar
Kishore_DharLv2Kishore_Dhar

Thanks for the chapter. I'd say either save or kill Hermione. Her parents would be really hurt seeing her in this state. Save her and the trauma will be too much. No one in magical Britain cares about a muggle born student's mental health.

Truriy
TruriyLv2Truriy

for me you can save her if you need her, let her stay in the school, otherwise I suggest you save her by making her go to another school as I read in another fan fiction

Golden_Zaku
Golden_ZakuLv1Golden_Zaku

Save her, she's just a dumb girl. It would be fun to twist her away from Neville and Dumbledore's camp.

Henrique_Aaa
Henrique_AaaLv2Henrique_Aaa

Save her

Phoenix1998
Phoenix1998Lv6Phoenix1998

Save her or kill her. Dont let her fate be same as canon frank and alice

Phoenix1998
Phoenix1998Lv6Phoenix1998

Lol. Harry potter the gas lighter

hidalgo061191
hidalgo061191Lv6hidalgo061191

Save her

VoidCrosser
VoidCrosserLv4VoidCrosser

Save her she is an integral part of the original golden trio So in the future without her the story would not have the same cohesion that it had now She is like a bridge between harry and the trio

Jin_Kazaragi
Jin_KazaragiLv4Jin_Kazaragi

Merci pour le chapitre ! Je vote pour sauver Hermione mais avec la faite qu'elle est restée des années dans le rêve ou elle a essayé de s'en échapper et y a appris pleins de choses sur la magie et l'a fait mûrir.

watzJ
watzJLv4watzJ

Thanks for good chapter~

hamid_bashiri
hamid_bashiriLv1hamid_bashiri

Save Hermione

UnknownWriter4Fun
UnknownWriter4FunLv4UnknownWriter4Fun

Bro, don’t kill off Hermione, you have a great dynamic going, secret friends in the future would be a good choice. She could always be his link to Neville and Ron. This would also force Harry to be more involved with “the golden trio”.