Uh, okay, what could you expect to gift someone who has everthing? Lucky she has creativity. If not, even a simple gift wont be counted as "sincere" just because he doesnt really like the present
I understand his disappointment. He is someone who values sentiment and that is something that has been clear since the beginning. He gave her his mother's ring but also gave her something that belongs only to her. Cuff links are generic gifts that don't require any thought.
I think why hes disappointed in the gift is because he probably get expensive stuff and remember they havent known each other that long. Alicia was thinking what kind of present can she get a man who could get everything he wanted and its a thoughtful gift of monogram cuff links from his new wife.